BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

A Scandal In Belgravia » What I missed after the pool scene » July 9, 2012 2:44 am

imane nikko
Replies: 9

Go to post

I don't know about "not worth viewing," exactly. I think I'd watch a show about Sherlock watching paint dry. 

But it wouldn't have contributed anything essential to the story, and they needed the time for other things.

Sherlockian Merchandise » Sherlock Jewelery » July 8, 2012 6:04 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 32

Go to post

I'm not a John/Sherlock shipper, but their friendship is my favorite thing about the show, so I bought this one:

http://www.etsy.com/listing/96892093/bbc-sherlock-johnlock-scrabble-tile

The Hounds Of Baskerville » Questions about the Episode » July 8, 2012 5:35 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 72

Go to post

Sherlock Holmes wrote:

SusiGo wrote:

imane nikko wrote:

c) At the end of Scandal, Mycroft responds to Irene's mention of Moriarty by saying "Yes, he's been in touch. Seems desperate for my attention, which I'm sure can be arranged." So I think that Moriarty is likely taken into custody shortly following those events and remains there throughout Hound.

That's one thing that wasn't clear to me. Can we deduce from this that Moriarty gave himself up in order to get into contact with Sherlock's brother? Because I think a master criminal like him would only get caught if he wanted to. Sorry if that has been discussed somewhere else, I happened to read this thread only now.

Yeah I think Moriarty definitely chose to give himself up, because he thought he would be able to get information about Sherlock from Mycroft (which he did, clearly).

Definitely. The whole thing was planned on Moriarty's side (and probably on Sherlock/Mycroft's too).

Other Adaptations » The Holmes (the calico cat) Mysteries » July 6, 2012 1:42 am

imane nikko
Replies: 1

Go to post

I bought these DVDs of a show that aired in Japan in April, purely for the title. The main character, Katoyama, is a policeman, but he thinks he's not suited for it and prefers cooking or possibly working in a flower shop. His father was a policeman, though, and wanted SOMEONE in the family to carry on the legacy... so his sister and mystery-writer brother insist he tough it out.

The titular character is a cat that hangs around the women's college where the murder in the first episode takes place. It hates everyone except Katoyama. It also transforms into a very fat, very made up man who gives him a pep talk about how he's the only one who can solve the case.

Thus far it appears entirely ridiculous, but I think it must be something of a parody of Sherlock, because apart from the title, the hero's got a bright red button holding open his left lapel.

If I notice any other references, I'll post them here.

Benedict's Non-Sherlock Work » Benedict Cumberbatch to Star in the Simpsons » July 5, 2012 9:15 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 53

Go to post

Neil Gaiman recently did a voice acting stint on the Simpsons too... I think stars usually appear as themselves or as a character they're famous for. It's not a stepping-stone, it's a badge of honor... kind of hokey, maybe, but like getting your star on the walk of fame.

Anyway, if something both Neil Gaiman and Benedict do is wrong, I don't want to be right.

Current Affairs » American Presidential Elections » July 5, 2012 7:27 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 29

Go to post

LOL at Tantalus.

I'm voting. Will choose Obama although I'm not thrilled with him. Guess expecting to be thrilled by politicians might be asking a bit much.

I'm not horrified by the candidates so much as the incredible influence of money in our political system and the distorting effect it has on our politics. Not so much in the presidential race, actually... it's more insidious at lower levels.

Any candidate or party that credibly promised to move to publicly funded elections would have my vote in a heartbeat. That way the politicians could stop trying to please the deep pockets, wealthy businessmen like the Kochs on one side or the labor unions on the other, and start actually doing the work of governing. They'd have to get something done, because it'd be the only way to win votes.

Meet The Members » What Deductions Would Sherlock Make About You? » July 5, 2012 6:10 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 73

Go to post

I wish Sherlock really existed, because I'm sure he could see some things I have no idea about.

But this is what I can think of: he'd know I work indoors because I'm pale. He'd know it wasn't hand work, because my nails are too long. They're filed but unpolished, so he'd know I make some attempt to be presentable but can't be bothered to spend too much time on maintenance. No makeup, so he'd know that my job doesn't require a highly professional appearance. I don't wear much jewelry, so most days no clues there. But on the days I do wear something he'd be able to guess where I've traveled, since I like necklaces as souvenirs. From the callus on my right middle finger he'd know I'm right handed and enjoy writing longhand. On some days there are ink stains, and he'd be able to identify walnut ink (naturally) and deduce from that that I am interested in calligraphy or pen sketching. From the scars on my left hand, he'd know I've also done some kind of work or project that involves short knives or exacto blades, but that I haven't cut myself recently, so either I've lost interest or become more careful.

If he had access to where I live, of course, he'd know simply everything. :D

Fan Videos » Sherlock Song Spoof » July 5, 2012 5:22 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 3

Go to post

The Bieber thing is genius.

The Hounds Of Baskerville » Fear of Moriarty? » July 5, 2012 4:49 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 15

Go to post

I think Sherlock's afraid of Moriarty, but he's got control of it under normal circumstances. The drug took away that control, which is also why he feared the hound  (or more accurately, feared the fact that he saw something he knew to be impossible).

Benedict's Non-Sherlock Work » Benedict Cumberbatch to Star in the Simpsons » July 5, 2012 12:51 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 53

Go to post

Does this mean there's going to be a Sherlock-themed Simpsons episode? I might actually watch that.

Other » National Stereotypes » July 3, 2012 8:40 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 229

Go to post

My stereotype about Finland is that your ladies like to sit on rainbows and trick passing heroes into accidentally chopping themselves with axes.

Fan Fic » Mycroft fanfic...with CAKE! » July 3, 2012 1:29 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 2

Go to post

This is wonderful. I'm definitely going to try to make it.

Also, when I was little I was a huge (original) Trekkie... the author of this fic is also the author of my all-time favorite Star Trek novel (Spock's World). I guess I shouldn't be surprised she also writes fan fiction. What's a Star Trek novel, after all?

General Sherlock Discussion » What would you say if you met your favorite Sherlock actor? » July 2, 2012 7:44 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 75

Go to post

Steve Moffat I'd just ask to please write more sheets into Sherlock.

Fan Videos » Japanese Commercial based on Study In Pink » July 2, 2012 6:32 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 15

Go to post

Uh... I'm not Jimella. But you're welcome!

General Sherlock Discussion » What would you say if you met your favorite Sherlock actor? » July 2, 2012 5:53 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 75

Go to post

I'd keep it short and sweet... just "Sorry to disturb you, but I just have to tell you how much I enjoy your portrayal of (whatever character). Thank you, and I wish you the best in your career."

And *then* I'd go somewhere out of sight and pass out.

Fan Videos » Japanese Commercial based on Study In Pink » July 2, 2012 5:25 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 15

Go to post

-Na-chan, what will you do when you quit AKB?
-To tell you the truth...
[scream]
-What?
-She's dead.
[CASE FILE #1]
-It can't be true.
-Leave it to me!
(group) -Na-chan!
[text over armor: Original idea by Yasushi (?) Akimoto]
- The victim is Rena Kato. She was clubbed to death while filming a commercial.
[text over lamp/bust: Original story by Somebody Aoyama] (I'm sorry, I'm terrible at reading names.)
-The clues are the letter N and this mysterious code. Who was on the scene?
-Nobody apart from the members (of the group).
-All 89 members of AKB are suspects.
-But taking out Na-chan...
-... and the victim too...
-All but two!
(group) -She changed how she said it.
-Will the mystery be solved first, or the ice cream melt first? Aisu no mi! (In Japanese the word for "solve" is the same as the word for "melt" so this is a pretty catchy slogan. Aisu no mi,or Ice-cream Fruit, is the brand name of these little ice cream balls.)

Introductions Please... » Introductions are dull. » July 2, 2012 4:59 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 16

Go to post

Dull? Your introduction?

Wrong!

Character Analysis » Sherlock- Asperger's syndrome and sociopathy » July 1, 2012 4:50 am

imane nikko
Replies: 259

Go to post

sherlockskitty wrote:

  While many laypeople use the term “antisocial'  to apply to people who are introverted and uncomfortable interacting with large numbers of people, mental health professionals use it very differently. When a psychologist or psychiatrist diagnoses someone with antisocial personality disorder, they mean that the person exhibits “a pervasive pattern of disregard for and violation of the rights of others'  (DSM-IV), which typically involves criminal acts, chronic lying, physically assaulting others, disregard for others’ safety and needs, and lack of remorse for one’s actions. 

I don't quite understand why this part is in the article.   I don't like interacting  with large groups of people,  in person, that is,  but that's because I have a severe hearing loss,  and I'm afraid I'll say something that's totally wrong.  All I 'hear'  is background noise...which  is why I hate noise.   So--- does this make ME  anti-social?  I've been told I don't have any 'social skills'  but I don't believe that.   I  have personal friends,  but not too many,  which suits me fine. I'll admit to a little lie  now and then,  but that's it.

My  point is,  the statement above is not taking deaf ppl like me into consideration.   In my opinion they are only referring to normal hearing ppl like Sherlock.

"Laypeople" means non-psychologists. That part of the article is comparing common usage of the term "antisocial" (untrained people think it's synonymous with "introverted") and contrasting it with the meaning of a diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder (which includes all the bad stuff (lying, lack of empathy, etc).

It's an interesting point that certain conditions, such as the kind of deafness you describe, could produce "introverted" behavior in non-introverts.

Character Analysis » Sherlock- Asperger's syndrome and sociopathy » July 1, 2012 12:35 am

imane nikko
Replies: 259

Go to post

Davina wrote:

Those with Asperger's do have  emotional empathy. It is cognitive empathy they have a problem with.

Sorry, I misremembered the terminology used in the article. Drawback of posting from my phone!

But the point I was making stands, I think. Cognitive empathy is required to manipulate people as Sherlock does in those acting scenes. Making a diagnosis is hard, especially since the terms themselves have some fluidity (for example, I've seen 'sociopath' differentiated from 'psychopath' by saying that sociopaths are able to form emotional attachments to some people, and toward those specific people they will experience emotional empathy... guilt for hurting them, an aversion to causing them pain -- which seems an accurate enough description of Sherlock's character).

Really, I think the problem is we're dealing with an actor's portrayal of a fictional character. No reason that the onscreen Sherlock can't mix and match diagnoses. So usually he misses social cues and has emotional empathy/a conscience like an Aspie, but he can pull out the sociopath when the situation calls for it.

Character Analysis » Sherlock- Asperger's syndrome and sociopathy » June 30, 2012 9:52 pm

imane nikko
Replies: 259

Go to post

I think Sherlock isn't really either one. In general I get more of an Asperger's feel from him, but he does have a great deal of empathy when it's convenient -- the few times he's "faked" neurotypical behavior it was with great facility.

His false tears with the wife of the "murdered" banker in the Great Game, the "I've forgotten my keys" speech to get into the apartment in the Blind Banker, and his impression of the vicar in Scandal... maybe I'm misinterpreting what Asperger's is, but those impersonations would be very hard for someone who lacks the emotional empathy the article describes as the province of sociopaths.

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum