BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

Reichenbach Theories » Detailed Analysis of St Barts Location » May 24, 2012 5:10 pm

Britigander
Replies: 13

Go to post

Absolutely! "Good job" not-tobe-messed-with Librarian
Living in London is even more fun when on can do this kind of thing
Thanks for posting the url Sherlock H. :D


[Offtopic]
Also love that 'London' is subtitled 'Londinivm', presumably to help any time-travelled Romans who came through the Cardiff rift
[/offtopic]

Moftiss » Moffat: People who find SH & DW 'too complex' are stupid » May 24, 2012 11:59 am

Britigander
Replies: 3

Go to post

Sigh. It really doesn't do to be seen as 'clever' in the UK (unless things have changed a lot),to generalise to save time as I have to run to the bus in three mins, but of course he has a point about the complex soap operas. Human brains are good with complex issues if they are about social things but poor if it is expressed in mathematical terms, even if they represent the same reasoning. I think Prof Dunbar (now at Oxford) showed this (bizarrely I was involved in suggesting him as a speaker at a surgery conference once when the organiser was trying to encourage the attendees to think outside the box and get involved in research.
     What about all those people even if a minority who like complex things, I would ask the non-complexity fans?Sigh. It is so tedious being dominated by some other common denominator.
Agh!
Bus!!
*running*...

General Sherlock Discussion » List your favourite episodes in order » May 24, 2012 3:47 am

Britigander
Replies: 93

Go to post

sammy wrote:

And, as you mentioned - "That's what people DO!" was just woah. Startled me quite a bit.

Beware of these words! Every time some one says (eg on the news) 'People have died' I feel this incredible urge to quote this reposte. And adapted versions for '..have died' or 'People have...',  which is not always appropriate.
Perhaps I watched this scene slightly too many times?

Meanwhile back at the Ordering of Episodes, here are mine, despite protestations from the librarians in my brain that there are several equally valid but different (oh,except for last place) ways of defining favourite and therefore episode order.

1. Pilot version of SIP
2. Fall and Hounds
4. The Woman
5. Official version of SIP
6. The Pool but also what came before that
7.  Pass the cliche-bag please, Banker

This is based on how I feel during/after watching/recalling the episodes and not necessarily on the many rational/consciously percieved values that these episodes have. I find suffering such as injustice/grief but particularly people very distressed as they're going to be blown up by baddies, extremely hard to watch and hear at some deep emotional level and basically have to fast forward through these bits or feel awful for days. Weird because in emergencies and so forth I am very calm, and can often do things that other people are squeamish about (pick up spiders et al).

1. I didn't see The Pilot version of SIP for ages as I was so grateful at having the actual episodes I completely didn't look for anything else on the disks. Then I did and OMG, it felt so life-like, internally consistent and convincing, I couldn't watch any of the real episodes for over a week! I've only ever watched it twice so as not to remind myself. I accept the decision from TPTB that it had to be done differently. Its their job to know what's going to work.

7. m0r has said everything I could possibly say to justify my decision about this position for this episode and far more su

Introductions Please... » Hello from Ann Arbor » May 24, 2012 12:43 am

Britigander
Replies: 19

Go to post

Thanks, Wholocked

...hmm, for a while I was always next episode-voracious, so to speak, but after whizzing through all the new series Doctor Who DVDs in 2 months flat a couple of years ago, and going cold turkey, decided I wanted to make the fun last longer in future, more like it's really only just happened.

I was quite surprised that PBS put Sherlock out only a week apart though!
   
But we all are, with time a-plenty to have fun with what we have, and er...catch up on reading? I'm so embarrassed to say I've never read any of the originals! But I have heard the Radio4 adaptations a number of times (on Radio4extra) since I've been in the US, and used to watch the TV versions too from an early age. I suppose they're probably on youtube in 8min chunks? I'll check this extensive web site for this topic.

Cheers!

BG

Introductions Please... » Hello from Ann Arbor » May 23, 2012 11:52 pm

Britigander
Replies: 19

Go to post

tobeornot221b wrote:

Willkommen, Britigander!
*passes shock blanket and chocolate*
So you'll be waiting for season 3 together with us? Good choice!
Enjoy...

Aw, vielen dank!
*wraps self in blanket*
Ah, feeling better already...
*eats chocolate as slowly as possible to make it last*
Definitely
Mmm, yummy continental chocolate.
Yep, I'm here, poised for some serious (and not so serious) Sherlockage.

Davina wrote:

Looking forward to spending some of the time we have to kill between now and series 3 in your company. (Apparently I am now 'staff' which is nice. Lol) Would you like a cup of tea and a mince pie?

Ditto, and congrats on the promotion!

Tea? So kind.

THough actually I'll pass on the mince pie right now, thanks, cos I'm rather full of chocolate. :$

(Edited because my fingers can't spell)

Introductions Please... » Hello from Ann Arbor » May 23, 2012 3:54 am

Britigander
Replies: 19

Go to post

Hmm, I'm just starting to go through all the things I wouldn't let myself open before :D Looking forward to it!

Unfortunately though at some point very soon I will have to actually get some sleep     I tried to talk my boss into watching 'The Hounds' on Monday but I fear he's a bit too, err, focussed on real life to see the funny side of the glowing rabbit, (since we've just spent a serious heap of departmental money on getting the fancy lighting one really needs to make GFP glow) let alone me dozing off propped on the scope!

So - nice to meet yer - and

Laters!

Introductions Please... » Hello from Ann Arbor » May 23, 2012 3:33 am

Britigander
Replies: 19

Go to post

Thanks, m0r, and enjoying the ease with which we can all converse across the miles

and

thanks and 'G'day' (it must be?) Kazza474... sounds a good plan indeed.
All the hard work of avoiding reading about it definitely paid off though. wipes away tear

Introductions Please... » Hello out there! » May 23, 2012 3:13 am

Britigander
Replies: 12

Go to post

Hi Carl  - Just read you are in LA. Sigh. Brings back happy memories of humming birds and walking in Griffith Park.

Introductions Please... » Hello from Ann Arbor » May 23, 2012 3:06 am

Britigander
Replies: 19

Go to post

So glad to find this forum! I've really enjoyed reading the different views and ideas about these amazing programmes and would like to join in too ...

About me: I'm a Brit but have lived and worked in the US for years now but lived and worked in London for quite a few years before that. Jobwise:  I know one end of a microscope from the other (but don't keep thumbs in my fridge).

I like a lot of things about living here but I still miss the UK a lot. Thank goodness for DVDs, and cheers, PBS, for enabling me to watch series 2. =)

Am still getting over the shock of seeing TRF yesterday evening. I'd managed to keep myself pretty much spoiler-free.

(Still taking a while to remember out how to post properly, etc etc so please bear with me).

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum