BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

Reichenbach Theories » Sherlock did NOTHING to fake his death. » August 6, 2013 2:55 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 37

Go to post

SherlockianDE wrote:

I remember Steven Moffot saying in an interview something along the lines of "If Sherlock Holmes is going to fake his own death, it better be the best faked death of all time, and I think it’s pretty good". So that pretty much affirms for me that Sherlock DID plan to fake his death...

f you consider what Sherlock looked like on that pavement, there is no way this would classify as "minimal injuries". Just the amount of spilled blood in itself would indicate the severity of the injuries.
Which brings me to what sj4iy wrote: if Sherlock had been injured like that, there's now way he could have been standing at his grave soon after, looking totally unscathed...

Rats. 

Reichenbach Theories » Sherlock did NOTHING to fake his death. » August 6, 2013 2:01 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 37

Go to post

I'll try to address all the points raised in one post. 

-What Sherlock realizes upon leaving Kitty's flat ("He’s been sowing doubt into people’s minds for the last twenty-four hours. There’s only one thing he needs to do to complete his game, and that’s to ...") is that Moriarity needs to eliminate any remaining believers (i.e. Sherlock's friends) before he can take out Sherlock himself or he'll be stuck with troublesome loose ends that might investigate and reveal the truth.

-Sherlock's words to Molly were, "Molly, I think I’m going to die," not "Molly, I think someone's going to try to kill me" or "Molly, I think someone's going to try to force me to kill myself."

-The moment of privacy was to see if he could think of any other way out.  Sherlock often requests privacy to think, in the form of being alone or demanding silence.  And sure enough, he DOES figure a way out and start to smile.  He realizes Moriarty accidentally revealed that there's an off switch.

-People do survive falls with minimal injury, even from parachute heights.  His request to Molly was, "If it looks like I committed suicide but I live, make people think I died or innocent people will die."

-Similarly, he encouraged John to spread the myth ("I created Moriarty") to protect the innocent, so they'd refrain from prying after the fact and get themselves killed.

-Sherlock told John to stay where he was to keep him from getting shot.  If he'd approached the door to St. Bart's, the assassin would have fired.  It would have been his last chance to do so.

-Moffat loves writing emotion (think of all the emotion-rich scenes in SiB...humor, sorrow, tenderness, embarrassment, lust, etc.).  Revealing that Sherlock jumped purely to save his friends would totally be his style and fit Sherlock's growth pattern throughout the series and episode. 

Reichenbach Theories » Sherlock did NOTHING to fake his death. » August 5, 2013 8:34 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 37

Go to post

In this theory, there will be a 3rd series because he survived, not because he faked it.  The only trickery would be having Molly cover it up should he happen to survive.

Reichenbach Theories » Sherlock did NOTHING to fake his death. » August 5, 2013 7:58 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 37

Go to post

Howdy, all.  I'm trying to find discussion of my favorite theory, that Sherlock did nothing to fake his death, that he went over that ledge fully believing he was giving his life for his friends.  Has anyone seen this theory before? Can you point me to a discussion?  Thanks.

General Benedict Appreciation » Is Dr. Who a desirable role? » July 24, 2013 7:53 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 19

Go to post

No disrespect to the Whovians.  Truly.  TRULY.  I mean it.  Like whatever you want.  I watch SURVIVOR and that Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders reality show.  But for the life of me, I can't imagine why Benedict would want to play Dr. Who at this stage in his career.  I've never been able to watch more than a couple of minutes.  The writing is so campy, it's hard to believe it comes from the guys from bring us SHERLOCK.  For Benedict, who works on stuff like SHERLOCK, PARADE'S END, 12 YEARS A SLAVE, and THE FIFTH ESTATE, taking on DR. WHO would be like giving up ARGO and BREAKING BAD (or MAD MEN or THE WALKING DEAD) to be on the Beverly Hillbillies or a wrestling show.  Am I way off base?  Have I somehow only managed to see bad snippets of what's really an excellent show?

Soundtrack » Favourite Sherlock Soundtrack » July 3, 2013 6:54 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 49

Go to post

I absolutely adore this violin trio of "The Game is On" (they call it Taxi Chase).  And bless 'em, they provide an mp3 download link!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rHDCJmzajQc

Series Three News » Has the weather affected filming? » June 24, 2013 2:12 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 11

Go to post

beekeeper wrote:

well all I can say is that in Cardiff we know how to layer our thermals. 

Question about that.  THIRD STAR takes place in Wales, yes? Saw it for the first time last night.  How come, most of the time, they're all bundled up, night and day, as they hike..but then, when they get to the bay, suddenly it's warm enough to swim?  Naked, even?  I assume this is somehow related to why Sherlock, no matter where he is in the UK, is ALWAYS wearing his coat outside, no matter what time of year it is...

 

General Sherlock Discussion » Common law spouses » May 30, 2013 9:21 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 3

Go to post

You know how Martin and Amanda are referred to as common law spouses?  I have some questions about that.

1.  What makes people common law spouses in the UK?  Living together for an extended amount of time?  If yes...

2.  Why weren't Benedict and Olivia considered common law spouses?  Or were they?

3.  Can common law spouses just separate at will, without having to go through any financial or legal hurdles?  In SILKWOOD, there was a line about how Karen and her husband had to go through the divorce process, even though they never actually married, because of common law.

4.  Is the phrase "common law" derogatory, antiquated, or resented?  Would Martin or Amanda ever refer to him- or herself as being part of a common law marriage?

Character Analysis » D'you think Sherlock has ever had a girlfriend? » May 2, 2013 7:13 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 261

Go to post

besleybean wrote:

Which kind of ruins the impact of Molly in Reichenbach and(I hope in) the new series.

Time isn't linear in my fantasies.

Character Analysis » D'you think Sherlock has ever had a girlfriend? » May 2, 2013 7:06 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 261

Go to post

dory1006 wrote:

Even if Sherlock is unattached, maybe he had one experience because he wanted to try...

In one of my fantasies, he asks Molly to deflower him after the Irene Adler fiasco because he realizes how desperately he needs greater understanding in this area.

Character Analysis » D'you think Sherlock has ever had a girlfriend? » April 30, 2013 8:37 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 261

Go to post

My thoughts: 
 
1.  Cute as I am, I've never really had a romantic relationship and I'm approaching 50.  Abstinence isn't that tough.  I find it unbelievable that unmarried people actually uproot and move (or choose a university) just to maintain a relationship! 
 
2.  Sherlock is inexperienced because he has been a loner, something people choose when other humans have been a source of more pain than pleasure.  As he grows, he will learn how to prevent that pain, and that all worthwhile things in life come from other people.   
 
3.  Because of the criticism and coldness he endured growing up (criticism and coldness create loners) Sherlock probably assumed he was undesirable and therefore incapable of landing anybody he really wanted.  As a result, he probably didn't even try.  Attention and the occasionally stolen kiss from those who fancied him would have been insufficient to persuade him he was desirable.  He would have assumed anybody attracted to a loser must also be a loser.  
 
4.  The show's creators will maintain Sherlock's virgin status because Moffat is correct.  "...it's someone who abstains who's interesting."  Dangle something desirable in front of the fandom, say "No one can have him," and watch the obsession proliferate.  Everybody wins!

A Study In Pink » The Pilot » April 30, 2013 4:28 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 130

Go to post

Carol the Dabbler wrote:

I don't offhand recall much "pink" in their flat, but it was red in the pilot, so maybe it averages out kind of pink!

Must be my settings.  On my tv, it looks Pepto Bismol pink!

Meet The Members » Need help from folks with London tube knowledge » April 18, 2013 1:52 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 20

Go to post

What's a faffy platform change?  Where shouldn't you make eye contact?

Meet The Members » Need help from folks with London tube knowledge » April 17, 2013 9:29 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 20

Go to post

Must...control...excitement....

I know!  I'll sing!

"Let's all go down to Oxford Circus
Past Trafalgar Square and then from
Charing Cross right up to Euston..."
 

Meet The Members » Need help from folks with London tube knowledge » April 17, 2013 8:37 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 20

Go to post

Thank you, thank you!  If I see Benedict at the airport, I'll snap a pic for everybody.  Yeah, I suspect he's leaving the country just as I arrive...for all those STID premieres.

MNRebecca, off to plot the routes to Speedy's, St. Bart's, etc.

Meet The Members » Need help from folks with London tube knowledge » April 17, 2013 6:53 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 20

Go to post

Sherlock Holmes wrote:

If you're planning on getting the tube from Heathrow, it'll be the Piccadilly Line all the way to Earl's Court.

Thanks for all the help, folks.  I think I'm zeroing in on the problem.  Country mouse doesn't know how to read a tube map.  Here's the portion of the map I'm referencing.  Ignore the text in red - that's me telling Aunt Jackie how I plan to get from Heathrow to Base2Stay.

Here's what I see.  The solid blue Picadilly line goes from Barons Court to Gloucester Road WITHOUT ANY STOPS IN BETWEEN (because there are only stops where there are names, right?).  So how can it go to Earl's Court?  And why is there a blue wheelchair icon on the Picadilly line between Barons Court and Gloucester Road when there's no stop there?  Could it be I'm reading the map correctly but it's an old map?  It got it from http://www.tfl.gov.uk/ (specifically www.tfl.gov.uk/assets/downloads/standard-tube-map.pdf).

Okay, yeah, laugh it up.  Then educate me please please please!!!!!

R.

Meet The Members » Need help from folks with London tube knowledge » April 17, 2013 3:49 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 20

Go to post

The folks at the "LondonsTransport" Yahoo group rejected me, so may I please burden y'all for some help with my upcoming trip to London (first time out of North America!!!!)?  It's my job to get Mom, who can't walk far, from Heathrow to Base2Stay in Kensington, which is:

1.  A one-block walk from Earl's Court station (but NOT on the Picadilly line, right?)
2.  A three-block walk from Gloucester Road station (but ON the Picadilly line, right?)

My aunt Jackie (former Londoner) says using the interchange after Gloucester Road to get the District Line to Earl's Court will involve MASSIVE amounts of walking and that finding the correct way out of the Earl's Court station can be challenging.  She suspects there are easier ways to get from Heathrow to Base2Stay.  Like what?  Getting off at Gloucester Road?  Barons Court?  We'll be traveling on a Sunday, early afternoon, if that's a factor.

MNRebecca, country mouse.

 

Meet The Members » POLL: Don't Drink The Water! » April 10, 2013 8:04 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 27

Go to post

MNRebecca wrote:

Actually, I think I'm staying completely in England.  London, Dover, and Cornwall.  That's all England, right?  But should I say Britain anyway?

Oh, oh, oh, I think I've got it!  Unless the exchange is lengthy and substantial enough to make it clear it's England and NOT GB or the UK, I say Britain.  Yes?

Or is it best just to avoid saying England unless anything else would be flat out wrong?

Meet The Members » POLL: Don't Drink The Water! » April 10, 2013 7:32 pm

MNRebecca
Replies: 27

Go to post

beekeeper wrote:

errrr....well our water should be pretty free of bacteria because it is treated to be. I've never heard of a vistor from another country having a problem with it.

Thanks!


beekeeper wrote:

(saying this very politely and gently. by "England" I'm assuming you actually mean "Britain".

Actually, I think I'm staying completely in England.  London, Dover, and Cornwall.  That's all England, right?  But should I say Britain anyway?

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum