The Reichenbach Fall » Taking the Pulse (Sherlock as well as Watson) » June 24, 2013 6:52 am |
I don't particularly like the ball-stopping-the-pulse theory. For one, where would the ball be when Sherlock is falling? Becuase if you have the ball-stopping-the-pulse theory, then the body falling is definitely Sherlock's. The ball most likely would not stay in place while he was falling, and we don't see him put it into place when he is lying on the ground. Also, that theory (to me) just doesn't seem very Sherlock? I don't know, it could be right, but I don't know...
The Reichenbach Fall » Something I'm absolutely sure of - preparations for the fall. » June 21, 2013 11:28 pm |
lil wrote:
sherlockian111 wrote:
lil wrote:
Think Airbags . like in a car .
The photo of the homelessy like man on the bench below b4 the fall has 3 bags .
After he is stood right by the body , and no sign of any bags ?
Was it a 3 large airbags solution ?
After all John couldnt of seen Sherlock land , and further once the bags had exploded ~ almost nothing left but dust and a few empty bags tht would go nicely into a coat pocket .
Stuntmen fall onto air bag type landings alllll the time .
A little fake blood and a Dazed @ Confused doctor @ Voila.
Done in seconds with almost no remaining evidance. .I quite like your theory, but the one problem I have with it is, how did Sherlock know that Moriarty would kill himself? How did Sherlock know that Moriarty wouldn't have anybody else watching? Also, wouldn't John's sniper have seen those airbags?
Also, this is quite a minor detail, but the creators of Sherlock said there were clues pointing towards the solution, and, as far as I can tell, there aren't any clues pointing towards your theory.
Hmmm , The landing site was almost always obscurred , the bus , the yellow lorry , the smaller building . Planned that way likely.
…
The sniper on John was targeting John and probably only watching SH periphically. .
After all " It's just a magic trick " ~ people see what they expect to see when they've been set up to see what you want them to see.
Sherlock did ask M to stand back,,,,but I think SH was toying with him .
Either Moriarty made a boastfull mistake at the last moment about the recall code , (sir boastalot ha ) and SH took advantage of that , or more probably SH knew that he only had to shake hands with Moriarty for him to be shot somehow , like the two life saving assasins were ?
( "I've got you" ) ( " Shake your hand in hell " )
As for clues hmmm IOU using the Bach keycode ( French syle , fish/poisson) spells out BAG , but I don't think M would give Sherlock clues on how to fake his own
The Reichenbach Fall » Something I'm absolutely sure of - preparations for the fall. » June 21, 2013 5:46 am |
lil wrote:
Think Airbags . like in a car .
The photo of the homelessy like man on the bench below b4 the fall has 3 bags .
After he is stood right by the body , and no sign of any bags ?
Was it a 3 large airbags solution ?
After all John couldnt of seen Sherlock land , and further once the bags had exploded ~ almost nothing left but dust and a few empty bags tht would go nicely into a coat pocket .
Stuntmen fall onto air bag type landings alllll the time .
A little fake blood and a Dazed @ Confused doctor @ Voila.
Done in seconds with almost no remaining evidance. .
I quite like your theory, but the one problem I have with it is, how did Sherlock know that Moriarty would kill himself? How did Sherlock know that Moriarty wouldn't have anybody else watching? Also, wouldn't John's sniper have seen those airbags?
Also, this is quite a minor detail, but the creators of Sherlock said there were clues pointing towards the solution, and, as far as I can tell, there aren't any clues pointing towards your theory.
Reichenbach Theories » Sherlock & Moriarty Tea Scene » June 1, 2013 10:42 pm |
There's quite a bit of diamons/jewels and quite a bit of tea in the episode
Reichenbach Theories » Go on then...what are your theories? » May 30, 2013 9:47 am |
Yeah, there's also no actual wound anywhere on his head, there's just "blood". Grrrrrr, everthing I come up with seems to point to a dead end. And the clues that I've managed to pick up on, I have no idea what they mean! (if they mean anything)
Reichenbach Theories » Go on then...what are your theories? » May 30, 2013 9:30 am |
Mary Me wrote:
sherlockian111 wrote:
The only problem that I have with the net theory, is the fact that we actually do see him land on the pavement.
Do we? Or is it just a vision of what John believes he sees; what his mind does to fill in the parts he couldn't see? Was it really Sherlock we see land on the pavement?
Well, I suppose that could be the case but then that's kind of cheating. Sherlock's face when he's on the ground and there's the blood and stuff, then that could also be simply what John expects to see.
In all honesty, I don't think that's the case
Reichenbach Theories » Go on then...what are your theories? » May 30, 2013 7:24 am |
The only problem that I have with the net theory, is the fact that we actually do see him land on the pavement.
Reichenbach Theories » Go on then...what are your theories? » May 24, 2013 6:58 am |
I suppose, but then, he would have waited a while before coming back, and by the time he did, no-one would remember that detective who turned out to be a nutter. and it's not as if he's going to publicly announce himself to the world when he comes back. It all makes sense in my head, it's just hard to explain
Reichenbach Theories » Go on then...what are your theories? » May 24, 2013 6:49 am |
yeah, but it was the ideal solution to Sherlock's situation though. Faking his death gives him a much better chance to track down all of Moriaty's henchmen or whatever, and it also gives him the chance to prove that he isn't a fake. Also, I don't think Sherlock particularly liked being famous, so faking his death would give hima chance to 'disappear'.
Reichenbach Theories » Go on then...what are your theories? » May 24, 2013 6:29 am |
with the "there's only one thing he needs to do and that's to-", I think Sherlock realised that if people delve in a little deeper into the matter, they would discover that Sherlock is in fact real, and so Sherlock must have realised that Moriaty would need him to die almost immediately, and preferable die in disgrace, so people wouldn't delve any further into the matter. And what better way to die in disgrace then to 'appear' to commit suicide, right after his so-called 'secret' is exposed? However, if Sherlock died then there would be nobody interesting for Moriaty to watch dance, so I think Moriaty was already planning on committing suicide.
The Reichenbach Fall » Why not Molly? » May 3, 2013 6:47 am |
Sky Holt wrote:
^He did notice her efforts, and commented on them quite extensively. He just didn't realise they were directed at him, possibly because he's not used to having someone have a crush on him. Sherlock being Sherlock, he probably notices her, but as he's not used to the concept of love, he doesn't realise that Molly has a crush on him and may just think that that's how she normally behaves?
But unless Sherlock does actually fully end up appreciating her, if not actually fall in love with her (very unlikely!) then she probably won't be a target. Anyone watching them will think that she's just another collegue, and leave her alone like the rest of them.
Just wanted to say that I really like those poems at that appear at the bottom of your post! Seriously, they're really good! Obviously, the first one's from Humpty Dumpty, did you come up with the second one yourself? I'm guessing the 'do not blink' thing is from Doctor Who, but still, it's really cool!
The Reichenbach Fall » Something I'm absolutely sure of - preparations for the fall. » April 15, 2013 8:13 am |
Be wrote:
Be wrote:
Something I'm not absolutely sure of, but it is probably something Sherlock did to prepare for the fall:
1. somebody poured a great amount of blood on the ground;
2. but we see in Sherlock's face that the blood trail is nicely done to convince a doctor that the skull is fractured. You can see that blood comes out of the left ear and the nose. It runs vertical when Sherlock is positioned on his right side.
This second application must be done when Sherlock is already on the pavement. It can not be done by just pouring everything from above. Hypothesis: Sherlock did it himself in the few seconds before people approached him. How? Sherlock must have kept the blood in a small container. Something handy and someting which would allow him to be very precice with the amount of blood. And if it is real blood (his own?) it mustn't coagulate. Therfore it must be stired and moved to prevent coagulation.
Conveniently we see Sherlock moving someting excessively. What if it is not a rubber ball but a manual rubber pipetting aid. He is in the laboratory where there are all kind of devices. We can find this kind of balls in chemical laboratories. And they look like rubber balls. You use it to apply liquid onto slices. We see Sherlock using pipettes througout the series. Sometimes they are small and transparent and sometimes they are big. Depends on the amount of liquid you want to use. We see Molly with another kind of pipette in TRF. In The casebook you can find it when you look at the first picture with Sherlock and John in 221 b next to John on a small table. There it is a small white ball in a glass container.
Might be something, might be just my imgagination. But I think it fits with Sherlock's measuring the coagulation of saliva, the bouncing ball and pipetting.
What do you think?…
I changed my mind about the bouncing ball since I last wrote the sentences above.
At first I thought that Sherlock would use laboratory equipment and the ball must
The Reichenbach Fall » Shouldn't the "fraud" doubt begin and end here? » April 13, 2013 7:34 am |
BlinkULDHC wrote:
crazybbcamerican wrote:
Good point!
(OK I'll play! nowhere in Sherlock or the original canon did sherlock *ever* say "Elementary, dear Watson." He says elementary once or twice, and calls Watson dear a few times, but those words never appear together in the text :D So is that the one that doesn't belong?)You are technically correct, but only partially correct with respect to the entirety of the riddle.
You're on the right track....
Is it because it 'elementary, my dear Watson' doesn't make sense? Like Luke, I am your father. Do you feel lucky, punk? and then 'I don't think we're in Kansas anymore, Toto. Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn. Those more or less make sense, but 'elementary, my dear Watson' doesn't really fit in
The Reichenbach Fall » Some Things We Might Take For Granted as TRUE » April 12, 2013 11:59 pm |
Adding onto the list of things that we take for granted as true(honestly, the list goes on forever), what about this whole Richard Brook, Jim Moriaty thing? We already know that somehow, the evidence that Jim Moriaty is a real person disappeared. We're told that he did this using the "key code", however, there was no key code. So maybe, Richard Brook was real and Jim Moriaty was fake? That would explain why his name didn't come in the class lists in TGG
The Reichenbach Fall » Alan Davies: Jonathan Creek solved the mystery of Sherlock's fall » April 12, 2013 11:42 pm |
It's an interesting theory, but I highly doubt that they would use an idea from another TV series. Also, he's jumping off a 4 story building (think it's four stories), so it would be a bit harder
The Reichenbach Fall » Funniest Moment in The Reichenbach Fall » April 12, 2013 10:53 am |
Mattlocked wrote:
This seems to be a "funny" moment... Obviously after Reichenbach Fall
you know, it was actually raining at the end of that scene
The Reichenbach Fall » Sherlock was never on the building that he 'jumped off' » April 12, 2013 10:45 am |
Remember, he throws his phone away. And then he jumps, so I'm pretty sure it's Sherlock who jumps
The Reichenbach Fall » Something I'm absolutely sure of - preparations for the fall. » April 7, 2013 8:50 am |
Mrs.Wenceslas wrote:
I don´t believe the ball is what we alle are missing, according to Moffat, either.
I personally don't think the ball trick was used. It just seems too...obvious?
The Reichenbach Fall » Something I'm absolutely sure of - preparations for the fall. » April 7, 2013 8:44 am |
With the ball trick, you have to squeeze your upper arm against it, in order for the ball to stop your pulse. Sherlock's arm looks pretty limp to me, when John's taking his pulse. I could just be overlooking this, but still
Reichenbach Theories » Right so the truck theory... » March 31, 2013 12:00 am |
Someone said that Sherlock was falling for about 8 seconds, I'm pretty sure that's just because BC wasn't actually falling at the speed that you would be falling in real life, and so the fall took longer. I actually came up with the-assassins-who tried-to-save-Sherlock's-life-somehow-saved-him-from-going-splat theory, but I couldn't figure out a way for them to accomplish that. And also, with the ball theory, you have to squeeze your arm in order to not feel your pulse, and Sherlock's arm looks pretty limp when John is checking his pulse. And also, Sherlock couldn't rely on John not being in a state to check his pulse, as (because we've all agreed that Sherlock jumped), there would be adrenaline running through him, and so it would be very easy to feel his pulse if he had one