Offline
And the thing with this movie is, that we're certainly not talking about gratuitous violence here. Of course you can make a film about slavery without showing violence of any kind, but it would be a completely different movie then. I haven't seen the movie yet, either, but I am pretty sure that McQueen did what he did for a good reason. I'm convinced that in this case showing violence serves a very important purpose.
Having said that, I can absolutely understand when people don't want to see violence of any kind in a movie and I would never try to convince them to go and see it if they don't want to.
And I'm not sure about the word 'pornographic' in this context, either. I would call it a graphic depiction of violence, and that's it.
Offline
I was trying to think of how to explain why I understood how the word pornographic could be used to describe the violence in this film, when Mrs. Watson helped me out by posting a dictionary definition. Thank you very much! I have seen the word used to indicate something extreme or over the top, in the sense that something is obscenely more than the usual (whatever it is). So because the violence in 12 Years is frequently up close, in-your-face, more graphic than typically seen in movies, and occurs for a longer duration than is common in movies, I think the use of the word pornographic is apt. But, certainly, other people may disagree and that is fine. I don't want to belabor the issue, just wanted to explain how/why some people might see it that way.
Offline
Tonnaree, just don't watch Shame with an elderly maiden aunt...if you get my drift.
Offline
Davina wrote:
Tonnaree, just don't watch Shame with an elderly maiden aunt...if you get my drift.
Drift totally gotten. I hear Mr. Fassbender is not shy.
Offline
Sometimes a work of art, book, music or film, moves you so profoundly that words are simply inadequate to describe the experience.
12 Years a Slave.
Offline
Steve produces works of art, most certainly! That is his background and it shows in all of his films.
Offline
It's up for a few Golden Globes ^^
Offline
Yay!
Offline
Hmm... starts in Germany next Thursday. But I think I have to wait until the DVD release to watch it in the original version.
Never thought I would be so keen for English versions one day...
Offline
Don't they have original versions with subtitles in German cinemas? In the Czech Republic there are two versions, one dubbed and one with subtitles, so you can choose, or there is only one version with subtitles (or dubbed if it's a film for children).
Offline
Only sometimes they do. Most times the big blockbusters are shown in both versions. But most times only for a few screening and some only in smaller cinemas. I will have a look if the cinema where I watched The Hobbit shows it.
Offline
Just a glance:
Offline
Great pic. Looking forward to see the film.
Offline
I had to take it way too quickly, the bus was already speeding up
Offline
Well... planned to watch the film on monday. And also found a cinema where I can watch it in the original version.
Maybe Mary Me joins me again.
Offline
Watched it last week on a preview in Tate Modern: a beautiful film (relatively speaking, giving the topic) although, IMO not one in which one connects emotionally with characters,,which is - probably - director's decision. All performances are top notch but it didn't feel to me like watching "characters", rather archetypes: a wronged man, a desperate mother, a kind-but-weak-slave-owner, a twisted-sadist-slave-owner, a bitch and jelous wife, a good abolitionist and so on. B. is beautiful looking in this and his performance is as good as we came to expect of him, but even he has to fit the logic of the movie and doesn't emerge, IMO, as a character, but rather a type. I am not so much surprised that 12YAS didn't get GG for performance. I think it deserves Oscar for the best picture or/and for the best director, but it is not "actors" film (quite opposite to AOC).
Offline
12 Years a Slave is nominated for 9 Oscars
Last edited by Mali (January 16, 2014 3:02 pm)
Offline
I have plans to watch it on Saturday or Sunday afternoon. In original version, of course! Thankfully one of the small cinemas in Cologne shows it in OmU. Sometimes it's difficult to even get OV screenings in the area if it's not a huge blockbuster or overly hyped movie.
Offline
Which cinema in Cologne shows it?
Offline
The Odeon, apparently. Quite unusual, cause the OVs/OmUs usually show at the Metropolis. Never been to the Odeon, so I have no idea what that one's like.