BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

The Empty Hearse » Too many references? » June 29, 2014 1:12 pm

Lilith
Replies: 98

Go to post

As i have been referred to this topic I take the freedom to reply even though i am "Johnny-come-lately" here. 

Sherlock Holmes wrote:

My point is though, even if you HAVE seen every single other episode of Sherlock but aren't part of the fandom...it's too much.

i can reply to this. A friend of mine has seen all the previous episodes but he is not involved in any kind of fandom. Let me say first that he utterly loved season 3 (maybe more than i did) but he didn't get many things! I had a LOT of explaining to do. Funniest thing was that he didn't even know Anderson! I had to explain to him who he is, he really though that he is entirely NEW character (yeah, i know, not really paying attention i guess) 
Having said this, he did enjoy the show nonetheless. I guess that the "regular" viewers of that TV show can enjoy it but they miss out a lot of the subtle things, obviously. Yet it seems to work nonetheless. 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 28, 2014 12:08 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Before registering here i had read some topics and i enjoyed the civil discussions which were pretty free of fighting and bickering. I especially enjoyed the topic about What Sherlock Did, id est shooting CAM. Even though opinions really differed, folks here discussed it in a very civil manner and that was also a push for me to finally do register and join the talk. And yes, guys, that's a compliment to all of you for being able to have different views and standpoints and not getting nasty to each other! 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 28, 2014 11:43 am

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Thank you all for your input, it is interesting to me even though i clearly see it a bit different. 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 10:27 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

I will check it out for sure.
Apart from the fact that i really didn't find the one topic you linked here, it is also a bit tricky in general for newbies in forums cause in some forums it is not welcomed when you start several topics about the same thing (which i understand), in other forums it is frowned upon when you bump up an old thread (which i don't understand), so i am basically just feeling my way through here. 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 9:55 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Thank you! See, i was really browsing the forum left, right and centre but for a newbie there is so much stuff here and so many topics, i totally did not find this one. will check it out! Danke 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 9:28 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Thanks besleybean. I am new to that forum and i don't wanna be a nuisance. Posting my first topic and then solidly flying off the rails, i was just not sure if people might be annoyed. So thanks!

Mattlocked, get your point now, thanks! And indeed you have a point here. agreed, a party with a gazillion guests would have been much more disturbing 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 8:51 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Very much so. And sure enough it ended in superduper-hangover disaster complete with being really sick. He tried to spice things up a bit, i guess. But the message can only be ~ stay with one beverage! or something like that. (sorry for being hilariously off topic!) 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 8:44 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Yes, i know. He had a shot at the bar and spiked the beer with some hard liquor (is spiked the correct word??) 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 8:40 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Well, basically only because of John, no? That human factor, you can always rely that this is what makes things go horribly wrong! The human factor. Or .. make things really splendid, depends on perspective 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 8:35 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Mattlocked, that is interesting trivia (i also didn't know there is a difference), yet it was not quite my point. I didn't actually say i missed more guests to that night out  Having said that, i did enjoy that scene to a degree, it was well played and it was funny. It is just not really "my" Sherlock! *lament lament* Even though i loved the notion how he thought he can actually conduct the state of drunkeness but even the best laid plans can (and usually do!) fail. 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 7:09 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Thing is i don't buy so easily into Sherlock organizing a stag night only cause John wanted one (did he??) but this is just me. 
Ha, seriously i don't know how i managed that. And i have no idea really just how i managed to wait for the German tv broadcast of season three. But i did  Yet, admittedly, from the moment on i knew when it would be on telly finally, it was hell. Until then i was miraculously fine. 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 6:51 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Oh don't get me any wrong here, i loooved how they incoporated the different "how did he fake his death" theories which were flying around, that was superfun! It was tongue-in-cheek, a nod to the fandom, it was really really well done. And heaven's no, i am not saying they go and look around for ideas on the net! Totally not my point, that would mean i am saying they run out of ideas and take suggestions from fans. Nope, really not what i was thinking. Yet, that show is so popular and i am not entirely convinced that they can easily write without being influenced? I don't know? *thinking in progress* 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 6:18 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

I personally think they are aware what's out there. I don't doubt their professionalism and i highly admire their writing. They have surprised me so many times by creating an arc as SusiGo has said. Maybe it boils down to "everyone's a critic" ;) have to point out again that i really love that show and even when i wasn't (yet) entirely comfortable with season 3 (will re-watch) it is still a fact that i am really totally captivated by that show, otherwise i wouldn't wreck my brain about this and that. It is a good sign. I was just wondering. 

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 4:50 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

Thanks for your thoughts, Marta! Hmm, there must have been a stag night ? Says who? (says the man at the door, haha). Yeah, but really? Cause our Sherlock is ever so conventional? No wait, is he? 
The writers said it would very stupid if Sherlock wouldn't evolve and i fully subscribe to this. Yet it was quite a step away from the character they had been so painstakingly portrayed in the first two seasons. And in several ways. Not only was he more emotional (don't get me any wrong, i love that, personally) but he is kinda losing his game. He cannot figure out Mary (maybe didn't have the time but isn't he always so fast? Moriarty trial scene!) and he is completely wrong about CAM and his "archive" and he "solves" it by "just" shooting him? Okay, i drifting off my original issue, sorry about that. So yeah, i am not entirely sure if the writers aren't somehow influenced by all what is out there. That's why it is interesting to me how others see it. 
Btw, i didn't really have any expectations or wishes but maybe i am the odd one out.

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Was it too much fan service? » June 26, 2014 2:41 pm

Lilith
Replies: 36

Go to post

I am new to this forum and let me say for a start if i happen to post this in the wrong section i kindly ask the admins to move it, thanks. 
I don't even know how to start and i had a hard time naming my post. I have just read only a few of the suggestions and ideas for series 3 from way back. And i was a bit gobsmacked, really. Like people wondering about the re-union of Sherlock and John will look like and many wrote that John will most likely punch Sherlock ... it happened. Then people were discussing a possible stag night .. it happened. People were kinda suggesting Sherlock consulting the net for advice to prepare a stag night/wedding .. happened. He youtubed .. I actually haven't gotten much further. So i was wondering (because i personally just got that impression) if the writers have paid a bit too much attention to what is out there and what people actually wanna see? I personally have my issues with season 3 but i must say i have not really watched it several times yet as i did with the other 2 seasons. My opinion/impression might change after re-watching it (but for now i don't even really feel the urge to see it again) To make it clear, i liked season 3 but i was not really loving it. 
So my question is for your opinions ~ did they pay too much attention to what is out there in the fan world? Were they slightly too influenced by all the expectations/ideas? Or is it just me?

Films » Recently watched movies. » June 23, 2014 12:16 pm

Lilith
Replies: 826

Go to post

I am not a big movie fan but last night i watched the full length (almost 4 hours!) "Ludwig II" by Visconti and gee, was it awesome!
Movies i have seen in the cinema this year so far ~ Only Lovers Left Alive and The Grand Budapest Hotel, both totally fantastic! 

Introductions Please... » Hello :) » June 22, 2014 5:41 pm

Lilith
Replies: 11

Go to post

Hey! Mistakes in grammar are not tolerated  .. just kidding. German here as well, also only just registered a few days ago. Germany going strong, it seems. So .. hello! 

The Blind Banker » Noticed any mistakes? » June 21, 2014 7:56 pm

Lilith
Replies: 98

Go to post

Here is what bugged me a bit but really just a little bit. I don't think everyone has the A-Z and if they do, do they all have the same edition? Whenever going to London i go with my "Streetfinder" and it is ages old. But maybe i am the odd one  So if Sherlock would have bumped into me, bad luck, no A-Z but at least i could have spoken correct German to him, haha 

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum