Barker wrote:

Are people actually still hoping there will be a Series 5? Don't set yourself up for (even more) heartbreak my friends...
Short of kidnapping and forcing the writers to put together a new series I don't see how this can happen in the near future. They don't want to do what's already been done many times over, i.e . 'regular' adventures with middle-aged H&W so unless by some miracle they can think of another twist to the tale this is pure wishful thinking.

Do you have any interviews or articles to make your point?

tonnaree wrote:

Well, it's always possible that by the time Rosie needs her own bedroom that they'll still only be needing 2.
*wink wink* *nudge nudge*

You know that I love the way you think. :-D

Like what?

SusiGo wrote:

Schmiezi wrote:

Elementary started with them moving together by the end of the first episode if I really it correctly.

Just as in ASiP where they decide to discuss the rent at the end. 

Only they did not move together because they were friends. I think Holmes' Father paid Watson to check if he relapses.

I think. I've only watched the first few episodes and then lost interest.

nakahara wrote:

SusiGo wrote:

Schmiezi wrote:

Thanks for your post. It was very interesting to read! :-)

So it is not impossible that Eurus only made up Victor the boy. Why would she do that? Just because she can? It makes her look even more cruel.

To me it is more believable that Sherlock made up Eurus, i.e. that she is part of himself. 

Let´s not forget that Sherrinford, the facility containing Eurus together with her deadly games, was in Canon the original name for Sherlock himself. The man is that building, so to say.

I would love them to go thete in S5. Thst would be really really clever writing :-)

By saving Eurus who would be a part of himself Sherlock would save himself from loneliness.

Thanks for your post. It was very interesting to read! :-)

So it is not impossible that Eurus only made up Victor the boy. Why would she do that? Just because she can? It makes her look even more cruel.

I love that thought, nakahara. That would be in character for Eurus.

nakahara wrote:

Schmiezi wrote:

SusiGo wrote:

I just realised that Sherlock and Eurus are the only ones who ever talk about Victor Trevor. Neither Mycroft, nor their parents or John or the police or anyone else. A little boy died and no one thinks it necessary to even mention this. Always provided, of course, that anything of all this is real. Which I do not think it is. I would really like to hear an explanation in case the whole Victor scenario was real. Why is the end so hurried? Why is a dead little boy never mentioned by anyone save Sherlock and Eurus? 

I never realised that. I thought Mycroft was talking about him too, but he only hinted at Redbeard being important.

A very good point. Considering the irreal atmosphere of "The Final Problem" and the emphasis on Redbeard being a dog in S3, I am not all that convinced that Victor ever was real, tbh.
 

Like Mycroft really hinted at a dog in S3?

If you look around, you'll find that this happened to many forum members. I mean, it's not really crowded here at the moment. :-(