How long, prior to Nov 5th, did the carridge go 'missing' from between the train stations?

Long enough for it to sit in the siding whilst the bomb was assembled in it, or, did it have the bomb already in it whilst 'in service'?

SilverMoonDragonB wrote:

And I loved this! So adorable! 

 
Is this tiny hat suposed to imply that Sherlock has a huge head?

In the dialogue it is referred to as being from a male because of its large size.

kuma wrote:

After watching TEH I still wonder this. Moriarty was so powerful then why did he sent ONLY 3 killers for this final act? And who was the observer that informed about if Sherlock had jumped or not? Then how can Holmes brothers ignored that person and kept acting to fool John?
We can see in the third explanation that Mycroft arranged to kill the killer right after but since TRF, I've noticed that the killer stopped aiming and put down the gun, which means somebody must have seen Sherlock falling and informed his accomplices about it.

Whether the third explanation is the truth or a joke, this still confuses me. Any idea?


(His voice said "8 so far" in my head, haha.)

 
John's assasin would have seen Sherlock fall and so would have informed the others if necessary.

However, how did the assasin know that John would decide to go to the Hospital at that point? Another hole in the Anderson theory?

I think we should all agree that the ONLY correct solution will be one that cannot have holes picked in it. Sherlock would simply not allow there to be any doubt or risk to its total success.

Anderson's one has got so many holes and 'what if' factors.

This thread alone has shown that, let alone all the other web-sites, forums and discussions zones which are ripping it apart.

anjaH_alias wrote:

shylock wrote:

anjaH_alias wrote:

No, the little building is quite long. We get John´s perspective clearly to be seen from the camera  POV - he could see the body, but not the airbag.

 
I would not think that John would be stupid enough to to accept that the body would land in an area other than directly below where it fell from.

I think for a John in shock this was enough. And, again, the camera offers us his perspective - for a second he can see a body on the pavement, then he is knocked down. If there wasn´t the dead body he had seen nothing. That had been a magic trick then .

 
It would have been far easier to set up, and more convincing, if John had been knocked down (exactly were he was anyway) which was before he could see far enough round the building to the point where he would naturally be looking for as where the body should have landed.

anjaH_alias wrote:

mujie wrote:

SusiGo wrote:

The needed the corpse to bridge the period of time between Sherlock landing on the airbag, the air-bag being put away and Sherlock being placed and made up. In TRF we/John see "Sherlock" lying on the pavement before John is run down by the bike. 

Hmmm... I suppose. I thought that if most of the makeup was done while he was lying down, why not all of it?

Plus, what about Mycroft? Again, if it was so simple to get rid of the snipers, it would have avoided the whole mess.

It´s not about the makeup - Short before the bicycle "accident" John gets a glance of the lying corpse. And this can´t be real Sherlock for obvious reasons. So for a short moment they needed a body.
The makeup was planted during John´s knockout, not before.

 
but if John could see the 'body' he would also be able to see the air-bag. which for obvious readons Sherlock would have not got off of.

Has anybody yet looked at, or better still screen cap'd, the actors at the 'fan-club' meeting and the 'accomplices' at the final theory?

I'm still certain that the 'love trist' theory girl was key in the air-bag scene and there could have been others.

I know 'extras' are 'multi-use' but I don't think Moffat would make a mistake like that.

The air bag would have been too slow to position and dispose of.
Quicker would have been an open backed lorry , full of citrus fruit to cushion the landing..........Lemonentry

don't have twitter either!  Too old!

Couldn't be the truth because it shows one of the 'accomplices' (the girl on the corner) who was the 'fan' who came up with the Shirlock/Moriati love trist theory.