BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

Meet The Members » Tell us what part of the world you come from » March 23, 2013 7:27 am

romahp
Replies: 319

Go to post

Sherlockita wrote:

I am from India.. I am surprised to see that the maximum number of members here are from US and not UK but yeah, i understand US is a very large country in comparison to UK

  hey nice to meet someone from india! finally a fellow country mate... 

A Study In Pink » Mistakes - anyone notice any? » March 12, 2013 7:16 am

romahp
Replies: 52

Go to post

anjaH_alias wrote:

romahp wrote:

This is very silly, but it stuck out for me so here goes..
 In SIP, the scene when John is about to knock at 221B and SH joins him on getting out of a taxi and they are standing there talking on the pavement. Now, I should point out that SH later on tells John that he 's already moved in, which means he is already living there i.e. Mrs.Hudson is already his housekeeper. We never see them hugging or greeting each other on any other occasions when SH is entering or leaving his rooms. So when Mrs.Hudson opens the door and fondly hugs him, saying "Sherlock....", we assume that they are meeting after a long time! When in fact he's already her tennant! That seemed very odd to me, so yeah maybe you think it's stupid..yeah maybe it is!

He is still new in the flat, or? Just moved in, looking for a flatmate now. He even seems to have no own key at that time . So the hugs might be there because the whole situation is new. Btw: The flat looks as if Sherlock it still uses more for storage purposes. And: We see Sherlock hugging Mrs. Hudson more than one time, e.g. short before "the game is on" (when Sherlock leaves Baker Street).

Thanks, that makes sense now! :D

General Sherlock Discussion » You know you're obsessed with Sherlock when... » March 1, 2013 2:28 pm

romahp
Replies: 4132

Go to post

when..
You observe everything in your room to check if anyone has disturbed you sock index.
You see any picture of London landscape and all you can think is that it was in Sherlock's title track.
Everytime you hear words or phrases like Frankenstein, to the end of the earth, planes or pilots you have a crazy smile on your face and after that you are distracted for hours..

The Reichenbach Fall » A few questions » February 26, 2013 10:12 am

romahp
Replies: 19

Go to post

1. Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss once asked themselves of what kind somebody could be who frightens us to death nowadays. Their conclusion was - a suicide bomber. Somebody who is so much obsessed with an idea that he is even willing to kill himself. Moriarty is obsessed with Sherlock, to burn him and to kill him. For this he even resists the methods of Mycroft´s interrogations. On the rooftop finally he seems to have solved the final problem: Because there is no recall code Sherlock is willing to jump into his own death to save his friends. But then Moriarty fluffs: He accidentally reveals that there is a possibility to recall everything.Sherlock realizes that, convinced to get the code out of him, to maybe deduce it. He is not Mycroft and not the King´s horses. He is not even an angel, just on the side of them. He can convince Moriarty that they are still alike and Moriarty, insane as he is, believes this: If one is able to get anything out of him then Sherlock (at the point when he realizes that, directly at the end of the sentence "I am not one of them", there is a kind of thunder and lightening camera and sound efffect, the moment of Moriarty´s literal enlightment, if you want so). To bring his plan to a successful end he must necessarily kill himself. If Sherlock actually had get the code out of him in the end is left open, but more important is, that he also was convinced about that. So he was absolutely able to be deeply persuasive to Moriarty.
2. In short: Moriarty likes to see Sherlock dance. This is why he pretends to give him the key. And because the key´s in Sherlock´s head the assassins try to save his life on the one hand, but on the other hand they try to prevent each other to talk to him, even to touch him. "Last one at Sherlock is a sissy", the last one will get the key and was careful enough before not to get assassinated.
3. Sherlock must give John a reason for committing suicide. He can´t obviously tell the truth. The world shall bel

The Reichenbach Fall » How to survive the fall and the things out of character...... » February 26, 2013 9:38 am

romahp
Replies: 32

Go to post

Yup, I agree about the tears part! He's the Sherlock Holmes, he can cry on cue! I think what Benedict Cumberbatch meant was that he showed humility by asking John to tell everyone that he was fake, when of course he was trying to save their lives.If there is any other meaning hidden, then please explain!
 And yes, he was acting strange right from the beginning. I was surprised to see him posing in front of cameras, but he was of course planning it all just so that he could accept the most publicised cases to lure in Moriarty! Mycroft was in on it, so was Molly. But what I don't get is Moriarty's suicide. SH clearly didn't anticipate that, so what was he planning on doing to Moriarty? He was eventually going to jump because he had the world's best trained killers following him who would have tortured the key code out of him even when it didn't exist. So he'd have to plan a suicide, just the way in the original series except in them he was escaping Moriarty's right-hand man, Moran.  So the question remains, since how long was he planning this ?

A Study In Pink » Mistakes - anyone notice any? » February 26, 2013 8:47 am

romahp
Replies: 52

Go to post

This is very silly, but it stuck out for me so here goes..
 In SIP, the scene when John is about to knock at 221B and SH joins him on getting out of a taxi and they are standing there talking on the pavement. Now, I should point out that SH later on tells John that he 's already moved in, which means he is already living there i.e. Mrs.Hudson is already his housekeeper. We never see them hugging or greeting each other on any other occasions when SH is entering or leaving his rooms. So when Mrs.Hudson opens the door and fondly hugs him, saying "Sherlock....", we assume that they are meeting after a long time! When in fact he's already her tennant! That seemed very odd to me, so yeah maybe you think it's stupid..yeah maybe it is!

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum