BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

Films » Recently watched movies. » January 31, 2018 4:51 am

NoShipSherlock
Replies: 826

Go to post

Has anyone seen the film Phantom Thread?  I saw it last week and I really liked it though the relationship between the two main characters was quite bizarre.  So, it was a rather odd but intriguing film.  I found myself conflicted over some of the character's actions, but couldn't stop thinking about the film afterwards.
Would like to hear other's impressions of the movie if you've seen it.

Yitzok, I also saw Darkest Hour and thought Gary Oldman was excellent.  I also enjoyed it far more than I expected!
Would recommend both movies.

Fan Fic » Fanfics from forum members » July 18, 2017 1:09 am

NoShipSherlock
Replies: 631

Go to post

I have written some Sherlock fan fiction and finally got up the courage to post two of them on Fanfiction.net.  If anyone cares to read them, here are the links:
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12576984/1/Ms-Adler-and-Mr-Holmes  FYI, this one is a sex scene, though not terribly explicit. 
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12576967/1/Backed-Into-the-Corner  Drunk Sherlock visits Molly!

Added 1 more Sherlock and a Doctor Who story.

 https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12578371/1/Unguarded

https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12578380/1/Reaction-Time
Doctor Who fluff piece

The Great Game » The Great Game - frame by frame analysis » April 28, 2017 12:05 am

Very interesting read!  Thanks for the link, Vhanja.

TV Programmes » Legion TV program » March 28, 2017 11:28 pm

We can always hope for season five or at least a movie or special to see what our favorite boys are up to.  Would certainly love to see more! 

TV Programmes » Legion TV program » March 27, 2017 11:36 pm

Yes, next episode is the season finale and I believe it has been renewed for season 2.
At least we get 8 episodes per season and only have to wait 1 year for season 2 unlike Sherlock!     

TV Programmes » Legion TV program » March 24, 2017 11:52 am

Lautrela, the episode that just aired did a great job of explaining much of what is happening.  I think you will enjoy it.  I thought it was the best so far.  I have never really been into comic books or graphic novels either, and haven't tried to read this one.  But, I must say I have really liked many of the Marvel movies and television shows and I think Legion is especially beautiful and creative.

Current Affairs » Attack in London » March 24, 2017 2:06 am

So sorry to hear about the attacks in London.  Thoughts and prayers to all who've been affected by this tragedy.   Please be safe.

TV Programmes » Legion TV program » March 24, 2017 2:03 am

Is anyone watching the television program Legion?  I am thoroughly enjoying it.  It does not always make sense, but e special effects and visual effects in general are stunning, and episode 7 was brilliant!  Excellent story, creative, more great visuals.  Just wondering if anyone else has seen it and your impressions.

Other » Seeking travel advice » March 3, 2017 2:00 pm

Besleybean, I am sure we will walk through St. James park.  I did not specifically write it as it seemed to be part of the palace grounds on the maps.  Looks lovely!

I had not specifically planned to visit the zoo or mosque.

Agreed that we will most likely not be able to see everything on day 4.  It sounds like the V&A is highly recommend.  Would like to see the others, but they can be scratched if it is a nice day and we feel like doing the park or gardens instead. 
I will check into going to the Morris room for tea.
I had seen the Sherlock Holmes pub listed several times but wasn't sure if it was overly touristy.  Sounds like they have decent food, then?  We may check it out if we have time.

Diva, I hadn't heard of St. Katherine Docks.  Sounds like it might be a nice place to grab lunch!
Thanks!

Other » Seeking travel advice » March 2, 2017 10:21 pm

Ok. Here goes.
Nothing planned the day we arrive due to probable jet lag, time change etc.
Day 1. Tour Westminster Abbey, walk along the Thames to see Big Ben, Houses of Parliament, Trafalgar Square.  Visit the National Gallery-this would be a Friday so it should be open late.

Day 2 Saturday. Notting Hill and Portobello Market in the morning.  Imperial War museum later. 

Day 3. Buckingham Palace -- should be open to tour the State Rooms, changing of the Guard or the Horse Guard.  Churchill War Rooms

Day 4. Hyde Park, V&A museum and possibly the Science and Natural History Museums. Would also be interested in Kew Gardens and Brompton Cemetery

Day 5. Sherlock Holmes Museum, Speedy's Cafe, the British Museum and British Library, Regent 's Park

Day 6. Tower of London, Tower Bridge, St. Paul's Cathedral.  Would also like to try to get a photo of St. Bart 's Hospital which I think is in this general area and maybe visit St. Bart 's the Great church

Day 7. This is a "free" day where we would probably take a day trip

Day 8 Borough market, HMS Belfast ship (hubby 's request. ),  Globe Theatre, Tate Modern

Day 9-10 would be the days of the London Open House so we would be touring those sites

I am also planning to go to at least one play or concert and to have afternoon tea somewhere.

Suggestions welcome!!

Other » Seeking travel advice » March 2, 2017 9:57 pm

Thanks again for all the feedback.  I am thinking about maybe Bletchley Park and/or Greenwich. I did like the Imitation Game and the code breakers from the war are very interesting.  My husband is a big history buff so he would probably enjoy that.   Bath is also still a consideration.  May just have to plan a second trip to see all the places outside London!
We will definitely walk to many of the sites in London but I'm sure we will also need to use the tube or ride the bus, and the riverboat on the Thames seems like a nice idea. 
I am trying hard not to pack too much into any one day so we are not exhausted and to leave time for exploring.  That is one reason I am planning the trip myself instead of going through a travel agency or tour group.  I feel like you get whisked from one site to another but don't really have enough time to properly see things with a tour company like Trafalgar though I suppose it can make things easier in a way.
Is anyone willing to look at my itinerary and let me know if it sounds doable?  It is rather long.  I can post it here or private message.
Thanks again for all the wonderful suggestions!! Much appreciated!

Other » Seeking travel advice » March 1, 2017 2:28 pm

Thanks again for all the great suggestions!  I am planning to purchase an Oyster card for travel.  Both Bath and Bletchley Park sound interesting. Will have to do a bit more research.  I do hope to have time to check out Hyde Park and some of the other parks.  We normally try to visit US National Parks and like hiking, so this trip will be a bit different for us, but I am looking forward to it.
Cheers and thanks again!

Other » Seeking travel advice » February 28, 2017 12:30 am

Thank you both!  Bath does look beautiful.  I will definitely keep it n mind, though I keep finding more and more things to see in London.

Other » Seeking travel advice » February 25, 2017 2:34 am

Hello Fellow Sherlockians!  My husband and I are planning to visit London in September (inspired, of course, by watching Sherlock!).  We are looking to be in London proper for 5-7 days leaving 2 or 3 days for possible day trips out of the city. This will be our first trip abroad.
We are planning to be there for the London Open House weekend and, of course, to visit the Sherlock Holmes Museum and the site of BBC's Baker Street and Speedys Café on Gower St. plus lots of other museums and sites.  There is a lot of good information online and I am planning to get some tour books, but, I was wondering if any of you have any suggestions for hotels or bed and breakfasts for our stay or maybe a recommendation for the best neighborhood in which to stay?  We don't need luxury accomodations, just looking for simple, clean and moderately priced.  It seems like there may be a few good places in the Covent Garden area. We are hoping not to have to rent a car--it sounds like it is fairly easy to walk or take the bus, tube or other public transport.
Actually, one other silly question regarding car rental.  If we were to take a day trip out of London by train to Oxford or Cardiff or someplace like that, are attractions at our destination city within walking distance of the train station, or would we need to take a taxi, or bus or rent a car to get around?  I can't seem to find much information on this subject.
Any information would be greatly appreciated as well as any thoughts on must see attractions or things to avoid. 
Thanks!

The Final Problem » The Final Problem: First impressions » January 24, 2017 11:56 pm

NoShipSherlock
Replies: 359

Go to post

Liberty wrote:

Irene - for me it was because of what Eurus said - about you don't understand Bach - "play you".  And apparently you/Sherlock is romantic yearning.   And I'm glad that's just as far as it went.   But I like the idea of Sherlock having those romantic feelings and secretly seeing them as what he is. 

 
I think this has been mentioned a few ties about Eurus asking Sherlock to "play him" and he chooses Irene's theme, but I just took it at face value that he composed that music therefore it was "him" or his music rather than Bach, not necessarily any underlying sexual meaning to it.  Though, I suppose Eurus' comments about sex after hearing it could give the impression of a deeper meaning to his song choice.
Sorry, I know this is a minor point and rather old hat by now, but it had bothered me for some reason!

The Final Problem » "I love you": a man's perspective - oh, just read it... :D » January 24, 2017 11:17 pm

The "male perspective" was interesting, but I do not agree that he was expressing romantic love for Molly.  Much of this has already been said here, but I think Sherlock genuinely respects Molly especially as the seasons progress.  You sort of get a sense that he is using her position in the morgue to procure bodies and other things in Study in Pink, but, over time I think he values her more and that he is truly indebted to her for her help in faking his death, and he knows how valuable a friend she is. 
I think he does love her as a friend, and I think his second "I love you" was a genuine expression of that love.  But I didn't get the impression that he thought of her romantically or sexually.  He was also trying desperately to save her life, but I think the emotion was real.
His smashing the coffin was in my opinion a combination of relief that she was spared and frustration that he was forced or manipulated by Eurus and that he may have hurt Molly.  It is also possible that he was upset by having to face such intense emotions and just needed an outlet to deal with emotions he has kept closed off for so long.
I don't think Eurus planned these scenarios to make Sherlock face individual emotions, though that is an interesting notion. 
Even though it wasn't shown, I'd like to think that Sherlock explained the situation to Molly afterwards and that they are still friends.

The Final Problem » What would have happened to Sherlock if Mycroft had died in TFP? » January 23, 2017 12:03 am

Good points!  I know Sherlock would be devastated if he were to lose Mycroft, but  I think Mycroft would actually be worse off were he to lose Sherlock as he seems to be more alone than Sherlock.  At least Sherlock would have John and other friends to support him. 
I do like the idea of Lady Smallwood being Mycroft's confidante and, yes, I think she could look out for Sherlock if appointed to do so.

The Final Problem » What would have happened to Sherlock if Mycroft had died in TFP? » January 22, 2017 9:03 pm

I had been thinking about what might have happened to Sherlock if Mycroft had died in TFP.  Not so much emotionally but I was thinking more practically about whether he would have been able to continue his duties as a consulting detective.  It seems to me that Mycroft affords not only some level of protection to his brother due to his status in the British government, but also that he afforded access to some places, such as Baskerville, that Sherlock would otherwise not have had.  Mycroft also uses Sherlock's abilities and has even put him in harm's way a few times as well. 
I have no doubt Sherlock's deductive abilities and cleverness would have remained intact and that he could still help with police work, but I think many of the things he was able to do to gain information would not be possible without Mycroft. 
Any thoughts?
 

The Final Problem » Mycroft in TFP » January 22, 2017 8:42 pm

Rache wrote, "When [Mycroft]  insulted John I was thinking for a second: wtf, Mycroft, how can you say this?? Then I understood. Anybody else who was irritated for the blink of an eye, or did you immediately see what he did? It was the ultimate horror/agony in this episode."

Yes, I had a few seconds where I thought Mycroft was being a real jerk, but I quickly realized what he was doing and it was all the more poignant when I did see through what was happening.  And how noble that he would have sacrificed himself so that John would be spared. 
      I agree with all of the posts here about Mycroft!   Mycroft was extremely well-written and executed, especially in this last episode.  Excellent work by Mark Gatiss! 
      I love the interactions between Mycroft and Sherlock in this episode.  They manage to be heartfelt without becoming maudlin.  Those scenes could have easily become over-the-top with emotion or laughable or even just flat and not believable, but they found a such delicate balance and managed to convey both sentiment and humor, and a sense of real history between the two--how a real family or real brothers would interact if their lives were in danger.  Just beautifully done. 
      These type of male to male character interactions are what draw me to the show (I am female by the way, if it matters).  I think, at least in American television and movies, we so rarely see either the deep type of friendship portrayed by John and Sherlock or the brotherly love showed here by Mycroft and Sherlock.  The closest I can think of is Lethal Weapon.  No one ever thinks twice about female friendships like, for instance, Meredith Grey and Christina Yang on Grey's Anatomy being portrayed in the manner of being soul mates but not sexual partners. That is how I see John and Sherlock.  Soul mates, but not partners.  To me, that is more special and unique a portrayal than viewing them as a couple.  Likewise, I think we rarely see as

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum