Hiya...I tried running a Sherlock book club on here (the threads are still up) but nobody ever really got into it. I would happily give it another go though, now we've got a few more members and people are suggesting it again.

I'll start a new forum called Sherlock Book Club, and move all the previous topics to there, then we can start new ones within that forum.

The basic premise is that we decide on a story from the canon, then we all go away and read it. We have a deadline by which we have to read it, then we come back and talk about our favourite bits etc. No one particularly needs to run the book club....I'll start a thread where we can discuss what book we'd like next, and then someone just starts the main thread for that book and like Kitty suggested, using the standard canon 4 letter abbreviations.

I've got another crazy idea for a topic,  but I don't know what to title it as. 

What  one person does,  is post a quote from the series OR  from the canon.   The NEXT  person tries to guess the NEXT line that comes right after  that,  and writes it in his/her post.  After they are declared right or wrong,  then that person posts the next game.   But,  we've got so many quote games going,  I  don't know.  (On the other hand,  what's one more quote game, eh?)

A canon quotes game is a great idea!

And no I don't think we should say what story it's from because you can easily find it out using google. And maybe whoever puts the next line in should also say which story it's from before posting their own quote.