Mmm I think Sherlock getting duped by the designated dupee would be kind of a big deal in a show that's all based on Sherlock's undupeability (lol that's never a word). They'd at least give us a shot of Janine's knowing face or like I said something like a "ha I knew it all along, you smartass" in the hospital scene. The simplest and most logic explanation in this case is that she was, actually, duped.

She said she heard shouting, and apparently recognised Mycroft's voice.

How could she recognize his voice at all?

Yes, that could explain it.

I just watched HLV again and I recognized that CAM looked at Sherlock after he said Janine would make the funniest noises... I wonder if he knew about them? Because I guess she wouldn't have told him, that he let them in...

Yeah, well how does he know?
And yet again, remember Janine saying at the wedding "You gonna be incredibly useful"

If CAM didn't know about her and Sherlock before the day Sherlock was shot, but afterwards, it would mean, that he knew she betrayed him by letting Sherlock in. So did he knew and they both manipulated Sherlock? Or maybe even Mary was part of the plan? This would explain, how she got in, why Janine was so healthy so fast again and why Mary did not shoot CAM? Maybe Mary was helping CAM to get Mycroft through John and Sherlock? Or maybe just get Sherlock out of the way??

Last edited by zeratul (January 15, 2014 11:05 pm)

you guys, the thing that shocks me the most about Jeanine is - how can this chick be so flipping chirpy and happy when she's on her way to work, when she's the PA to some wacko crazy weirdo who apparenly flicks her face?!?!?

As a PA myself, I personally would call in sick every day

LOL Janine's one tough girl. Worked for a sociopath, dated one... Girl better retire to the countryside 

Just a minor point, but I thought it quite appropriate that the writers didn't make Janine wear the purple shirt.

The PSOS is sacred.  None shall touch it's magnificence save but Jawn.