BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

The Hounds Of Baskerville » Cell vs. Mobile phone » January 31, 2013 7:49 am

BlinkULDHC
Replies: 10

Go to post

So, if Bob Franklin (the Baskerville scientist) moved from Indiana/USA to Devon like 25-30 years ago, how is it that he adopted the regional accent, yet somehow still (or, already?) calls the cell phone a "cell" and not a "mobile"?? 

First of all, 25 years ago (circa late 1980's), cell/mobile phones were nowhere near ubiquitous, so it's doubtful he even had one at the point that H.O.U.N.D. was running.  But apparently, not only did he have one, he became SO attached to calling it a "cell" that his subsequent 20+ years in the UK did nothing to change his name for the phone (despite the fact his American accent is completely gone). 

In America, I'm pretty sure that the first cell/mobile phones were still called mobile phones anyway, and this was in like 1992, long after Franklin had left the US. 

It's one thing if it's an American transplant who just moved to the UK 2 months ago, or even 2 years ago -- and is still stuck with "cell."  But a grown man who moved to the UK before cell phones became "cell phones," and still refers to it as such 20+ years later?  Does not compute.

Hell, I'm an American, and after watching just 6 episodes of Sherlock, I've damned-near started to refer to apartments as "flats."


It sounds trivial, but it's actually a key clue for Sherlock to deduce that Franklin was an American, THE American from H.O.U.N.D. who moved over to Devon. 

Introductions Please... » Hello! I'm a disappointed ***Sherlockology*** visitor » January 31, 2013 6:58 am

BlinkULDHC
Replies: 27

Go to post

I assumed that Sherlockology.com would be "THE" place for us Sherlock (BBC) fans (since it won an award for "Best Fan Site in Social Media).... but it doesn't even have a message board!  A show like Sherlock doesn't just demand discussion, it thrives on fan discussion. 

So, how can you win an award based on being the best "fan" site in "social" media, when you completely ignore the fans and deprive them of means to socialize?

Anyway.  I just downloaded both seasons, er, series (sorry, I'm an American, or yank), and watched all 6 episodes over the last 2 nights, and I'm hooked.  THIS is how Sherlock should be protrayed, if portrayed in the modern times. 


Elementary on CBS (with Johnnie Lee Miller) is NOWHERE close to Sherlock in terms of writing quality, direction, wit, drama, comedy, and most of all, the "heart and soul" of S ACD's works. 

Elementary's ONLY relation/connection to Sherlock Holmes is in name only.  It does not contain Sherlock's easter eggs and nods to true fans, it doesn't contain Holmes' core personality cues (like the cold analytical machine at work), it doesn't nearly come close to challenging  the viewer with its "deductions," and most of all, it completely maims the relationship between Holmes and Watson. 


This is rambling on and on.  Anyway, I'm Blink, love how the beeb has modernized Holmes, can't wait for season 3!

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum