BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

Reichenbach Theories » What happened to Moriarty's body? » March 19, 2012 1:25 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 11

Go to post

Ha, ha, kazza! Never book a flight with  Holmes Airlines, lol!

Reichenbach Theories » What happened to Moriarty's body? » March 19, 2012 1:18 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 11

Go to post

Moriarty is dead. MoGiss said, that they have no intention to bring him back; and in the original story, he also dies. The lack of gore, cited by many as an argument for M's survival, is simply due to BBC policy, that no spattered brain can be shown in this kind of tv show. Kids might be watching.
I always had the hunch, that M might have gone into Sherlock's grave ('I am You; You are Me'), since they needed a body for the funeral, and Molly might have helped.Thus Moriarty/Brook would just disappear, and nobody would know, what happened to him. But it's also possible, that this might go down as the suicide of desperately traumatized actor Rich Brook, and Sherlock will be blamed for it, making his own suicide even more plausible. Considering, that the police will certainly investigate the roof and find at least traces of blood (Molly can't very well clean everything in such a short time on a tar roof) I favour the second possibility at the moment. The tv audience just hasn't been told about the relevant news articles yet. This scenario of course raises the question, if Sherlock's grave is empty, and if not, whose body is buried there.

Reichenbach Theories » Mrs Hudson "Dying" » March 19, 2012 12:53 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 28

Go to post

Mrs. Hudson being ok was the whole point in sending John off to check on her. This way his reactions and from which direction he would arrive at the hospital, were perfectly computable for Sherlock, as well as the rough time frame.
Also, Moriarty realized correctly, that Sherlock has a heart after all for his friends. In fact, his whole plan was based on that fact. If he had arranged the call, John rushing off alone wouldn't have been certain at all.
It's interesting, though, to speculate, if M anticipated S's move to get J out of the way for a while. After all, the sniper, who was assigned to John, had to watch his movements. Interestingly, his arrival and preparation of the gun is shown AFTER M has committed suicide.

Reichenbach Theories » Mrs Hudson "Dying" » March 19, 2012 9:12 am

sherlocked
Replies: 28

Go to post

I've done a lot of reading and pondering over the weekend. A lot of people assume, that M arranged the call in order to use John as a count down clock, but that jarrs with a lot of details: S being completely unconcerned about Mrs.H is the strongest one. But S also wanted John as the witness of his fall. That only works with John being at a special location and a more or less computable time frame  on the street. So he had to get him out of the house for a certain amount of time. So, IMHO S arranged the call.

Latest News » Series 2 broadcast Germany- changes » March 13, 2012 6:44 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 3

Go to post

Yes, watching the original movies with subtitles is a wonderful way to improve language skills. My sons and their friends always watch movies like that. And as I said already, at least for me one of the greatest joys of Sherlock is Ben Cumberbatch's unique voice.

A Study In Pink » Which pill was the poisonous one?? » March 13, 2012 3:49 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 144

Go to post

ThecuriousOne, you are right. In a way the cabbie WAS dangerous, even without a pistol. He was playing mind games with Sherlock by challenging a weak spot brilliantly. It might have almost worked.

Sherlock, that would have been a better shot than Wilhelm Tell,who shot the apple from the head of his son, lol! But I would not put it past John to pull it off, lol!

Latest News » Series 2 broadcast Germany- changes » March 13, 2012 3:40 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 3

Go to post

davina, are you a fellow German? I've advertized 'Sherlock' amongst all my friends, though the dubbed version misses one of the greatest joys: Ben Cumberbatch's voice. I enjoyed the German version of the first season last year, which made me discover Sherlock, but I only got really into it, when I watched the dvd. I listen to the English version, with the help of the English subtitels. My English is good, since I lived in London and New York for a while, but the rapid fire dialog is too fast for me at times and the subtitels come in helpful.

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » How will Sherlock clear his name? » March 13, 2012 12:31 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 53

Go to post

Well, Sherlock said, that he doesn't need a public image, but that doesn't mean, it's strictly true. If he wants to have customers, it won't do to be considered a fraud. And some PR can't hurt either, as    John's blog demonstrated.

A Study In Pink » Which pill was the poisonous one?? » March 13, 2012 12:21 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 144

Go to post

The crazy thing about that scene: When John shot the cabbie, he didn't know, that the cabbie was of no danger to Sherlock, since he used only a toy pistol, and Sherlock knew it. The only danger for Sherlock was his own personality. I think, he was sorely tempted to take the pill, but snapped out of it, when the shot came. After all, he could have taken the pill even after the cabbie was dead, just to find out, if he had chosen the right pill, but the moment was over and some sort of sanity kicked in again, when he threw the pill away. If John had known all this, he might have shot the pill out of Sherlock's hand, lol! But we don't know, if he's THAT good with his gun!

Films » Blade Runner » March 12, 2012 6:18 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 15

Go to post

Yes, I got the director's cut. My sons are film buffs, they go for the best stuff. Rutger Hauer is great. I thought, it's a pity, that Sean Young's career never took properly off.
Gattaca has been available on dvd for quite a few years now.

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » How will Sherlock clear his name? » March 12, 2012 6:00 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 53

Go to post

Davina, I cannot imagine, that Mycroft turned M; he was out to get Sherlock, and, when he realized that he was beaten (I have an idea, what made him realize that), he killed himself. Really, not just pretend. But the thought, that the histrionic M was not the biggest spider in the web, occured to me , too. I see no other reason, why S would want to go undercover for any prolonged time. I mean, he could have come back from his pretend death after the snipers went away and his friends were safe, but at the start of the movie a month has elapsed already since Sherlock's supposed suicide. There must be a good reason for that. And the show needs a new good villain!

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » How will Sherlock clear his name? » March 12, 2012 1:31 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 53

Go to post

It's not about evidence, it's about suspicion. In the real legal world, there would never have been a warrant for his arrest, because there was not enough evidence for an arrest, in handcuffs no less. But not to be considered a fraud makes or breaks S as a consultant detective; without his good name he wouldn't get any cases, let alone interesting ones, and his brain would rot as he says himself.That said, we simply don't know, if MoGiss will have a more or less elaborate story line about Sherlock's rehabilitation.

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » How will Sherlock clear his name? » March 12, 2012 1:21 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 53

Go to post

Well, kazza, naturally I don't agree with what you say about my quotes (IF the Irene situation should be mirrored, I wouldn't say 'same old trick'; I would think it a clever symmetry), but I agree with you, that S will might be in the shadow for some time. It's even quite possible that he doesn't come face to face with John  immediately in the first episode. And he might look different as well. Ultimately it's all speculation. But I'd never say 'same old trick' about any idea before I've seen it,since it all depends on how it's going to be executed. I'd never thought, the Irene Adler concept would work, before I've seen Scandal. Now I consider it as one of the best in the series.

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » How will Sherlock clear his name? » March 12, 2012 9:53 am

sherlocked
Replies: 53

Go to post

The CuriosOne asked, how many times I watched the Reichenbach episode:

  Lestrade: How many times exactly did he fall out of the window?
  Sherlock: It's all a blurr. I've lost count.

Films » Blade Runner » March 12, 2012 9:18 am

sherlocked
Replies: 15

Go to post

Bladerunner is an all time great. I bought the dvd to give it to my sons. They liked it, too.
A more recent sci-fi movie I love, is Gattaca.

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » How will Sherlock clear his name? » March 12, 2012 8:20 am

sherlocked
Replies: 53

Go to post

Also, to a certain degree MoGiss open up possibilities and threads for a story line; if they really use them in the following season, is not certain. I listened to the audio comments of Scandal in Belgravia. If I understood correcty, they hadn't even thought how to resolve the great cliff hanger at the swimming pool at the time of the shooting. The idea with someone (Irene Adler) distracting M with an urgent phone call came after they had finished with the first season. They even reshot parts of the swimming pool scene to make a complete fit. So I think, they have thought out carefully the why and how of the apparent suicide, but what comes after that, is not decided yet. MoGiss even said so in an interview. A lot of things can happen, before they start filming again. Ben Cumberbatch for example remarked, how much his face has changed in the 18 month, which elapsed between the shooting of the first season and the making of Scandal. And he is right. His face has changed a lot from the slim boyish look in the first three episodes to a heftier more mature expression, we see in Reichenbach fall. Should he change even more, they might make the time gap between his fake death and his return larger.

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » How will Sherlock clear his name? » March 12, 2012 7:40 am

sherlocked
Replies: 53

Go to post

Recordings and photos are used all the time as evidence. There are even experts, who determine the likelyhood of manipulation. A recording of a phone conversation was one of the things that just toppled our president a couple of weeks ago. If it is about public opinion a recording or a photo sent to a newspaper is all it takes.
Anyway, Mogiss used exactly that idea (compromising photos, recordings and other data conserved on a phone) in the Irene Adler episode. If you argue, that photos can be easily manipulated, no one should be worried about compromising pictures anymore, you could always claim them to be a big fake. It's not so easy, there are tell tale signs of manipulation. To fake audio recordings is even more difficult.
As to the dropping of the phone: I dropped my phones many times like that. It was never damaged. Anyway, I don't think my theory, though of course I could be wrong, is very fancyful. Also we really don't know, if Sherlock will go into hiding for three years. They don't always follow the original canon. For example Irene Adler was never eventually outsmarted and subsequently saved by Holmes in Conan Doyle's story. Three years elapsed before Holmes returned, because Doyle originally wanted to write no more Holmes stories, and it took a while to change his mind, so a three year lapse was plausible.

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » How will Sherlock clear his name? » March 11, 2012 9:38 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 53

Go to post

Yeah, Sherlock, I wondered ,too, about the bugged appartment.
I like the idea, that Sherlock learned one or two things from Irene, being dead, when you're not, might be another one.  I like the parallels: Irene was thought to be dead, when Sherlock guarded her phone; if my guess turns out to be right, Sherlock is thought to be dead, while Molly guards his phone.
I also thought it a little stupid, that M never searched S for a recording device or body bugs; even in real death S could have proven his innocence, should he have been lucky enough to take the phone down with him in one piece. It would not have triggered the snipers to shoot, because they went away, as soon as they believed S to be dead. Oh well, it ain't easy to be a villain from the realm of fantasy.
So how would Molly or some other helper know to look for the phone? S could have called her after M was dead, or, since he had planned the jump in advance, he would have told his helper to collect the phone.
A lot of you guys asked, what Sherlock actually had planned for M. After all he could not really be sure that M would kill himself. And he could not very well do his fake jump with an onlooking Moriarty. I think, I've found a compelling theory, as well as some evidence in the movie itself, which you can only see, if you play the dvd in super slow motion. I will write about it tomorrow, because it takes a little time to put it together.
I know one thing for sure: If we finally know the solution, I will never ever watch the Reichenbach episode again, lol! Enough is enough!

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » How will Sherlock clear his name? » March 11, 2012 6:41 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 53

Go to post

Sherlock migh just have recorded the conversation with Moriarty on the roof with his phone (and maybe at his home, too, when he was having tea with M). That's why he dropped the phone onto the roof, before he jumped. So it would not get lost, destroyed or taken from him after the jump. A reliable person (probably Molly) could collect it, and keep it safe for Sherlock, until he comes out of hiding. It's the same situation as with Irene Adler's phone, which she sent to Sherlock for safe keeping. Irene's phone was her life insurance; Sherlock's phone could be his ticket for rehabilitation, and Molly sure would defend the phone with her own life.

The Hounds Of Baskerville » whats your favourite part of this episode?? » March 10, 2012 10:06 pm

sherlocked
Replies: 106

Go to post

You also have to consider that the dog might have been affected by the psychedelic fog as well. Maybe it was seeing gigantic Cheshire cats with a glow-in-the-dark grin. That would unnerve even the most good natured dog.
I would have taken the dog, too!

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum