Can´t choose - I like both equally.

It is hard to choose because they are such brilliant characters which are played fantastically.

tonnaree wrote:

I want to be in a sanwhich between them.  

..............and speaking of unwritten fan fiction ideas. 

Write it, Tonnaree!!

Ah-chie wrote:

I immediately chose Sherlock (because I just can't imagine voting against him and BC is so much of a favourite of mine!!) but I have to be honest when I clicked on the button to view the voting it broke my heart to see that no one had voted for John...  

I really felt like trying to vote again!  I do adore John.  He is such an important part of Sherlock and the two of them are more like "one" entity rather than competing elements.  It's almost unfair to have to make a choice!

-Val
 

And that made me vote for John Watson. 

Sherlock wouldn't be anything without John - and vice versa. I love them equally.

When I started watching BBC Sherlock, I admit I saw only Benedict. He eclipsed the entire show, and I couldn't really see anything else. But after a couple of episodes, I saw this awesome Dr. Watson on the screen. And these days, I watch the show just as much for Martin as I do for Benedict. 
 

I choose Sherlock, although he is not thinkable without Watson.

I"m with you gently.  You can't make me choose!

I applied the philosophy "What Would Sherlock Do?" and then voted for John.

I found a way to ease my guilty conscience (for not voting for John) - I voted for him on my iPad (registered in my hubby's name).

It was just tearing me up a bit, sort of like a "Sophie's Choice" sort of thing.

I think both the "boys" are just so brilliant!

-Val

I think it is hard to choose as they are one of the most well known pairs, with out the other person, they would be nothing. They are both halves which make a well known whole.
They are inseparable, no matter how much they argue.