Ozma wrote:

who do you not want to die?

Sherlock, John, Molly, Lestrade or Mrs. Hudson ...anyone else, I can deal with. It's not that I don't like Mycroft, but I could deal with him dying. Those five though.....
 

The suspense is too much!  Augh!!  The more I think about it the more possibilities there seem to be for who is going to be killed.  My biggest fear at the moment...what if they made Mary's character so likeable because they're going to kill John and have Mary take his place in the next season?  I just don't even know what to think anymore...

I'm gonna call a double bluff and say it's Mary. 

silverblaze wrote:

I'm gonna call a double bluff and say it's Mary. 

 
I really like Mary in this but I can honestly say I'd be relieved.  I can't see it working out well if she sticks around.

SilverMoonDragonB wrote:

Ozma wrote:

Weirdness wrote:

The suspense is too much! Augh!! The more I think about it the more possibilities there seem to be for who is going to be killed. My biggest fear at the moment...what if they made Mary's character so likeable because they're going to kill John and have Mary take his place in the next season? I just don't even know what to think anymore...

or we could just be stuck with Mary and John and the sacred family.

I doubt they would go that route, at least not for the rest of the series...they just wouldn't. Not only is it completely against canon, the show would suffer from a permanent rift between Sherlock and John like that, it just wouldn't be right to have him never living in 221b again....
 

 
Yeah, I suppose they wouldn't go that far against canon.  I don't doubt that they would possibly leave a cliffhanger that suggested something along those lines though.

Ozma wrote:

SilverMoonDragonB wrote:

Ozma wrote:

or we could just be stuck with Mary and John and the sacred family.

I doubt they would go that route, at least not for the rest of the series...they just wouldn't. Not only is it completely against canon, the show would suffer from a permanent rift between Sherlock and John like that, it just wouldn't be right to have him never living in 221b again....
 

So you do think that John will move back in, at some point (either in this ep or in the future anyway)?

I do think so yes, when and how and why....I don't know, but I have very little doubt that eventually John will move back in.
 

Ozma wrote:

SilverMoonDragonB wrote:

Ozma wrote:

So you do think that John will move back in, at some point (either in this ep or in the future anyway)?

I do think so yes, when and how and why....I don't know, but I have very little doubt that eventually John will move back in.
 

I do love you.

The bottom line is, the show would suffer if that didn't happen eventually. And as much as the Mofftiss likes to mess with canon, going that far off course just wouldn't make sense for Sherlock geeks like them . So we may see some rough times first, but John moving back in at some point is a near guarantee. 
 

Weirdness wrote:

SilverMoonDragonB wrote:

Ozma wrote:

or we could just be stuck with Mary and John and the sacred family.

I doubt they would go that route, at least not for the rest of the series...they just wouldn't. Not only is it completely against canon, the show would suffer from a permanent rift between Sherlock and John like that, it just wouldn't be right to have him never living in 221b again....
 

 
Yeah, I suppose they wouldn't go that far against canon. I don't doubt that they would possibly leave a cliffhanger that suggested something along those lines though.

^ I could see them doing that, yeah....evil-doers 
 

Last edited by SilverMoonDragonB (January 10, 2014 4:57 pm)

Hera wrote:

I really can't see John, Mary and a baby. John and Mary could be alright for a while, although I do hope that they won't keep her forever. If they really do have the baby and the show's still good, then I award Mofftiss my personal Oscar, because that just doesn't seem possible.

my sentiments exactly. I also love you, Hera.

I love you guys, too. I wouldn't survive the next few days without you!   ... By the way, not that I don't like Mary or Amanda - I think Amanda's Mary is the best possible Mary - but I love John and Sherlock together. I want a love story with John and Sherlock (not sexually, just bromance) and I want them to solve cases and get into lots of trouble. And - if John isn't a horrible husband and father, which I certainly don't hope - that's not possible with a whole family at home. I would hate my husband if he constantly risked his life.

Last edited by Hera (January 10, 2014 5:11 pm)