BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012 » What can I take to the moon?

Schmiezi · February 25, 2013 12:30 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.

Can you also take John's laptop?

Lily · February 25, 2013 12:38 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.

Schmiezi · February 25, 2013 12:50 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.

Can you take the skull?

Lily · February 25, 2013 2:00 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.

Yes: Sherlock, John, Mrs Hudson, laptop
No: Mycroft, Lestrade, Molly, skull

Hint: Actually I was only thinking of people but if you are being precise, you could say that I can take certain objects with me too, like the laptop. But that's only a coincidence because those objects are being carried or used by the people that I can take with me.

Last edited by Lily (February 25, 2013 2:08 pm)

Schmiezi · February 25, 2013 2:07 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.

Can you take one of John's jumpers?

Lily · February 25, 2013 2:09 pm

I edited my last post a bit, so I think you might want to change the question.

Sparrow · February 25, 2013 2:24 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene?

Lily · February 25, 2013 2:30 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.

Yes: Sherlock, John, Mrs Hudson, laptop
No: Mycroft, Lestrade, Molly, skull

Hint: Actually I was only thinking of people but if you are being precise, you could say that I can take certain objects with me too, like the laptop. But that's only a coincidence because those objects are being carried or used by the people that I can take with me.

Schmiezi · February 25, 2013 3:19 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.

Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you?

Yes: Sherlock, John, Mrs Hudson, laptop
No: Mycroft, Lestrade, Molly, skull

Lily · February 25, 2013 3:23 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.
Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you? - God, no!

Yes: Sherlock, John, Mrs Hudson, laptop
No: Mycroft, Lestrade, Molly, skull, Anderson

Hint: Actually I was only thinking of people but if you are being precise, you could say that I can take certain objects with me too, like the laptop. But that's only a coincidence because those objects are being carried or used by the people that I can take with me.

Last edited by Lily (February 25, 2013 3:25 pm)

Sparrow · February 25, 2013 3:28 pm

Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.
Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you? - God, no!
Can you only take people who live in 221? (that's the only connection I can think of with those three )

Lily · February 25, 2013 4:26 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.
Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you? - God, no!
Can you only take people who live in 221? . No!

Yes: Sherlock, John, Mrs Hudson, laptop
No: Mycroft, Lestrade, Molly, skull, Anderson

Hint: Actually I was only thinking of people but if you are being precise, you could say that I can take certain objects with me too, like the laptop. But that's only a coincidence because those objects are being carried or used by the people that I can take with me.

Schmiezi · February 25, 2013 4:29 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.
Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you? - God, no!
Can you only take people who live in 221? . No!

Can you take Irene Adler?

Lily · February 25, 2013 4:34 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.
Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you? - God, no!
Can you only take people who live in 221? - No!
Can you take Irene Adler? - I am not exactly sure. I checked on a certain scene but you can't really see if she qualifies or not.

Yes: Sherlock, John, Mrs Hudson, laptop
No: Mycroft, Lestrade, Molly, skull, Anderson

Hint: Actually I was only thinking of people but if you are being precise, you could say that I can take certain objects with me too, like the laptop. But that's only a coincidence because those objects are being carried or used by the people that I can take with me.

Sparrow · February 25, 2013 8:02 pm

Well, no offense, but you're not being very helpful. If you don't know, then who does? Your answers should be "yes" or "no". "Not exactly" and "I'm not sure" aren't helpful.

Lily · February 25, 2013 8:13 pm

In Irene's case it's just not obvious. There is a certain scene that could qualify her but it is not completely clear. I can't do more than double-check, if there is no visual confirmation, I can't give you a more accurate answer. :/
And the "not exactly" was intended to be a clue - I could have said no but the idea was heading in the right direction, that's what I meant.

This game usually takes quite a long time. I know it from a Harry Potter fan board and in the end it's usually an incredibly long list of questions. The more complicated, the more interesting it gets, I think.
You should just go on asking about certain characters, I will give more hints later.

Schmiezi · February 26, 2013 5:22 am

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.
Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you? - God, no!
Can you only take people who live in 221? - No!
Can you take Irene Adler? - I am not exactly sure. I checked on a certain scene but you can't really see if she qualifies or not.

Can you take Anthea?

Lily · February 26, 2013 12:33 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.
Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you? - God, no!
Can you only take people who live in 221? - No!
Can you take Irene Adler? - I am not exactly sure. I checked on a certain scene but you can't really see if she qualifies or not.
Can you take Anthea? - No.

Yes: Sherlock, John, Mrs Hudson, laptop
No: Mycroft, Lestrade, Molly, skull, Anderson, Anthea

Hint: Actually I was only thinking of people but if you are being precise, you could say that I can take certain objects with me too, like the laptop. But that's only a coincidence because those objects are being carried or used by the people that I can take with me.

Schmiezi · February 26, 2013 12:36 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.
Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you? - God, no!
Can you only take people who live in 221? - No!
Can you take Irene Adler? - I am not exactly sure. I checked on a certain scene but you can't really see if she qualifies or not.
Can you take Anthea? - No.

Can you take the CIA-agent that... "fell" out of the window?

Lily · February 26, 2013 12:37 pm

I can take Sherlock with me.
Can you take John? - Yes.
Can you take Mycroft? - No.
Can you take Mrs Hudson? - Yes.
Can you only take inhabitants of 221B? - No.
Can you take Lestrade with you? - No.
Can you only take things that have appeared in all episodes? - No.
Can you only take things with "h" in their name? - No.
Can you take Molly with you? - No.
Can you also take John's laptop? - That is actually a really good question. I can take a laptop but I'm not sure if it's John's or Sherlock's.
Can you take the skull? - No.
Can you only take people who were present in a certain scene? - Not exactly.
Could you (nobody would, but COULD you) take Anderson with you? - God, no!
Can you only take people who live in 221? - No!
Can you take Irene Adler? - I am not exactly sure. I checked on a certain scene but you can't really see if she qualifies or not.
Can you take Anthea? - No.
Can you take the CIA-agent that... "fell" out of the window? - No.

Yes: Sherlock, John, Mrs Hudson, laptop
No: Mycroft, Lestrade, Molly, skull, Anderson, Anthea