BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012 » Guess who or what I am!

Lily · March 6, 2013 5:40 pm

Are you seen in season 1? - No
Are you only seen in one episode? - Yes.
Are you seen in TRF? - No.
Are you in SIB? - Yes.
Are you an object at all? - Yes.
Are you seen outside? - No.
Do you belong to anybody in particular? - Yes.
Do you belong to Irene? - No.
Do you belong to John? - Yes.
Are you bigger than an apple? - Yes.
Are you seen at 221B? - Yes.
Does John hold / carry you? - Yes.
Are you seen during the Christmas Party? - No.
Does anybody except John use it? - No.
Is it important for the plot? - No.
Are you his Laptop? - No.
Are you something that is used for anything? - I'm not sure what you mean - everything is used for something, isn't it?
Is it seen at any place apart form 221B? - No.
Is is bigger than a soccer ball? - Mhm... yes, I think so. (It's a completely different shape, so it's difficult to tell.)
Are seen in the first 10 minutes of the episode? - No...
Can you be used as a weapon? - Yes.
Is it made out of metal? - No.
Are you a piece of clothing? - No.
Are you made of paper? - No.
Are you a piece of furniture? - No.
Are you the green plastic shopping bag? - No.
But maybe you are the Cluedo board? - No.

We only see it for maybe two or three seconds. I think it belongs to John - it could belong to Sherlock too or to both of them but John is the only one we see it with.

Myraya · March 6, 2013 5:51 pm

Something that we can see someone in but not a piece of clothing and no furniture...

Are you a mirror?

Mary Me · March 6, 2013 5:56 pm

Are you a cup?

Lily · March 6, 2013 5:58 pm

Myraya wrote:
Something that we can see someone in but not a piece of clothing and no furniture...

What? No, I didn't say that!

Are you seen in season 1? - No
Are you only seen in one episode? - Yes.
Are you seen in TRF? - No.
Are you in SIB? - Yes.
Are you an object at all? - Yes.
Are you seen outside? - No.
Do you belong to anybody in particular? - Yes.
Do you belong to Irene? - No.
Do you belong to John? - Yes.
Are you bigger than an apple? - Yes.
Are you seen at 221B? - Yes.
Does John hold / carry you? - Yes.
Are you seen during the Christmas Party? - No.
Does anybody except John use it? - No.
Is it important for the plot? - No.
Are you his Laptop? - No.
Are you something that is used for anything? - I'm not sure what you mean - everything is used for something, isn't it?
Is it seen at any place apart form 221B? - No.
Is is bigger than a soccer ball? - Mhm... yes, I think so. (It's a completely different shape, so it's difficult to tell.)
Are seen in the first 10 minutes of the episode? - No...
Can you be used as a weapon? - Yes.
Is it made out of metal? - No.
Are you a piece of clothing? - No.
Are you made of paper? - No.
Are you a piece of furniture? - No.
Are you the green plastic shopping bag? - No.
But maybe you are the Cluedo board? - No.
Are you a mirror? - No.
Are you a cup? - No.

Myraya · March 6, 2013 6:05 pm

Right, sorry, I misread this.

Are you seen in the living room?

Lily · March 6, 2013 6:10 pm

Are you seen in season 1? - No
Are you only seen in one episode? - Yes.
Are you seen in TRF? - No.
Are you in SIB? - Yes.
Are you an object at all? - Yes.
Are you seen outside? - No.
Do you belong to anybody in particular? - Yes.
Do you belong to Irene? - No.
Do you belong to John? - Yes.
Are you bigger than an apple? - Yes.
Are you seen at 221B? - Yes.
Does John hold / carry you? - Yes.
Are you seen during the Christmas Party? - No.
Does anybody except John use it? - No.
Is it important for the plot? - No.
Are you his Laptop? - No.
Are you something that is used for anything? - I'm not sure what you mean - everything is used for something, isn't it?
Is it seen at any place apart form 221B? - No.
Is is bigger than a soccer ball? - Mhm... yes, I think so. (It's a completely different shape, so it's difficult to tell.)
Are seen in the first 10 minutes of the episode? - No...
Can you be used as a weapon? - Yes.
Is it made out of metal? - No.
Are you a piece of clothing? - No.
Are you made of paper? - No.
Are you a piece of furniture? - No.
Are you the green plastic shopping bag? - No.
But maybe you are the Cluedo board? - No.
Are you a mirror? - No.
Are you a cup? - No.
Are you seen in the living room? - No.

Myraya · March 6, 2013 6:11 pm

Are you seen in the room downstairs where they take Mrs. Hudson when she has a shock?

Lily · March 6, 2013 6:51 pm

Are you seen in season 1? - No
Are you only seen in one episode? - Yes.
Are you seen in TRF? - No.
Are you in SIB? - Yes.
Are you an object at all? - Yes.
Are you seen outside? - No.
Do you belong to anybody in particular? - Yes.
Do you belong to Irene? - No.
Do you belong to John? - Yes.
Are you bigger than an apple? - Yes.
Are you seen at 221B? - Yes.
Does John hold / carry you? - Yes.
Are you seen during the Christmas Party? - No.
Does anybody except John use it? - No.
Is it important for the plot? - No.
Are you his Laptop? - No.
Are you something that is used for anything? - I'm not sure what you mean - everything is used for something, isn't it?
Is it seen at any place apart form 221B? - No.
Is is bigger than a soccer ball? - Mhm... yes, I think so. (It's a completely different shape, so it's difficult to tell.)
Are seen in the first 10 minutes of the episode? - No...
Can you be used as a weapon? - Yes.
Is it made out of metal? - No.
Are you a piece of clothing? - No.
Are you made of paper? - No.
Are you a piece of furniture? - No.
Are you the green plastic shopping bag? - No.
But maybe you are the Cluedo board? - No.
Are you a mirror? - No.
Are you a cup? - No.
Are you seen in the living room? - No. (I don't think it's the living room.)
Are you seen in the room downstairs where they take Mrs. Hudson when she has a shock? - No.

About the last question: I don't think it's the living room - I will take a look at the scene again...

Myraya · March 6, 2013 6:58 pm

Are you seen in the kitchen?

Lily · March 6, 2013 7:08 pm

Are you seen in season 1? - No
Are you only seen in one episode? - Yes.
Are you seen in TRF? - No.
Are you in SIB? - Yes.
Are you an object at all? - Yes.
Are you seen outside? - No.
Do you belong to anybody in particular? - Yes.
Do you belong to Irene? - No.
Do you belong to John? - Yes.
Are you bigger than an apple? - Yes.
Are you seen at 221B? - Yes.
Does John hold / carry you? - Yes.
Are you seen during the Christmas Party? - No.
Does anybody except John use it? - No.
Is it important for the plot? - No.
Are you his Laptop? - No.
Are you something that is used for anything? - I'm not sure what you mean - everything is used for something, isn't it?
Is it seen at any place apart form 221B? - No.
Is is bigger than a soccer ball? - Mhm... yes, I think so. (It's a completely different shape, so it's difficult to tell.)
Are seen in the first 10 minutes of the episode? - No...
Can you be used as a weapon? - Yes.
Is it made out of metal? - No.
Are you a piece of clothing? - No.
Are you made of paper? - No.
Are you a piece of furniture? - No.
Are you the green plastic shopping bag? - No.
But maybe you are the Cluedo board? - No.
Are you a mirror? - No.
Are you a cup? - No.
Are you seen in the living room? - No. (I don't think it's the living room.)
Are you seen in the room downstairs where they take Mrs. Hudson when she has a shock? - No.
Are you seen in the kitchen? - If you have good eyes.

Myraya · March 6, 2013 7:17 pm

Are you lying on a tabel?

Lily · March 6, 2013 7:24 pm

Are you seen in season 1? - No
Are you only seen in one episode? - Yes.
Are you seen in TRF? - No.
Are you in SIB? - Yes.
Are you an object at all? - Yes.
Are you seen outside? - No.
Do you belong to anybody in particular? - Yes.
Do you belong to Irene? - No.
Do you belong to John? - Yes.
Are you bigger than an apple? - Yes.
Are you seen at 221B? - Yes.
Does John hold / carry you? - Yes.
Are you seen during the Christmas Party? - No.
Does anybody except John use it? - No.
Is it important for the plot? - No.
Are you his Laptop? - No.
Are you something that is used for anything? - I'm not sure what you mean - everything is used for something, isn't it?
Is it seen at any place apart form 221B? - No.
Is is bigger than a soccer ball? - Mhm... yes, I think so. (It's a completely different shape, so it's difficult to tell.)
Are seen in the first 10 minutes of the episode? - No...
Can you be used as a weapon? - Yes.
Is it made out of metal? - No.
Are you a piece of clothing? - No.
Are you made of paper? - No.
Are you a piece of furniture? - No.
Are you the green plastic shopping bag? - No.
But maybe you are the Cluedo board? - No.
Are you a mirror? - No.
Are you a cup? - No.
Are you seen in the living room? - No. (I don't think it's the living room.)
Are you seen in the room downstairs where they take Mrs. Hudson when she has a shock? - No.
Are you seen in the kitchen? - If you have good eyes.
Are you lying on a tabel? - No.

Myraya · March 6, 2013 7:48 pm

Does John hold you?

Lily · March 6, 2013 8:05 pm

Yes but I already answered that.

I think you all just forgot that certain scene?
I checked all the questions again but it is al correct.

Myraya · March 7, 2013 3:13 pm

Ok, afer re-re-watching it I think I finally got it.

Are you the bottle of wine?

Lily · March 7, 2013 3:19 pm

YES! Finally!

Myraya · March 7, 2013 5:26 pm

That was very difficult! Not something that you notice normally.

All right, I've got something, you can start asking.

Lily · March 7, 2013 5:49 pm

Are you an object?

Myraya · March 7, 2013 5:53 pm

Are you an object? No

Lily · March 7, 2013 6:17 pm

Are you a person?