BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

Character Analysis » Sherlock- Asperger's syndrome and sociopathy » January 11, 2015 9:38 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 259

Go to post

I've never believed he was a sociopath, I've always thought it was just a label he gave himself to strike fear into the people who crossed him, socially. I always cringe a little at the 'High Functioning Sociopath' line for that reason (that, and the fact that there is no such thing as a HFS... it's just not 'a thing' as far as I know.)

As for him having an ASD... this seems more likely to me but, as he's a fictional character written by people who have no intentions of creating a character who is canonically on the spectrum, it is totally impossible to say for certian whether Sherlock is on the spectrum or not.

I have read arguements where people have noted that the only reason the creators have backed away from labelling him as autistic is because the creators don't want to have the scandal of such a huge character being autistic and then doing *really* terrible things (i.e. shoot a man in the face.) Having it open-ended like this allows the writers to 'bend the rules' with regards to how Sherlock interacts with the world around him. And allows them to get away with more for less 'accountability' for what they write. If this is the case it is, corporately, ingenious.

That said: I think it is wonderful that people with ASD/AS identify with aspects of Sherlock's character. If I had to chose a diagnosis (and not dance around the issue) I'd say AS more than sociopathy or Schizoid personality disorder. I've heard talk of him maybe being bipolar before, which was interresting, thoughts?

P.S. I've not seen many aspies getting all butt-hurt-y over people disagreeing over Sherlock having ASD: only with people who don't have autism telling them what ASD is or is not like/how it presents/how it affects them etc.
 

Character Analysis » Why Sherlock Twiddles stuff » January 11, 2015 8:39 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 12

Go to post

Benedict is a very fidgety person. The man has trouble sitting still. This tendancy has leaked into his performance as Sherlock, which goes very well with the fact that Sherlock is a very high energy character. (Making Benedict such a good choice of actor for Sherlock.)

Meet The Members » Post Your Absence » January 11, 2015 8:16 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 1858

Go to post

I know I didn't tell anyone I was going to disappear for over a year and a half, but I'm back for a while (shhh, Tumblr haven't noticed I'm missing yet!)

Meet The Members » What does your username/signature/avatar say about you? » January 11, 2015 8:07 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 172

Go to post

Wow, this is still going! I am so proud. I should have a picture of this thread with a certificate alongside it proclaiming my contribution to the internet.

Many thanks to everyone who has been adding to this thread whilst I've been away.

General Benedict Appreciation » I wonder about Benedict. » February 6, 2014 12:51 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 272

Go to post

SpiralStaircase wrote:

I wonder if he has ever played Tomb Raider.

 

And if he has I wonder if he ever totally sh@ himself on the level with the T-rex in it (assuming you're talking about the first game.)

Character Analysis » Sherlock's relationship with John Watson » February 6, 2014 12:13 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 14

Go to post

up501610 wrote:

I'm interested to know your thoughts on why Sherlock is so compassionate towards John? And why do most fanfic writers interperet this into a homosexual relationship? (Nothing against fanfic )

I think the fanfic writers who choose this interpretation do so for multiple reasons. I don't think it could be tied to just one reason. Some will do it because the notion titilates (that's a nice way of saying 'they wanted to write smut'.) Others will do it because they want to explore the good old magic 'if?' Some want to explore a particular aspect of a romantic relationship and feel these characters best match the story they are trying to tell.

They show such compassion to one another because they first and foremost share a great friendship. No matter what else goes with that. They are very different people but they understand each other in a way that few other people do. Most people would kill for that kind of connection in their lives, many of us will never attain it. Such a depth of understanding indicates intimacy (not necessarily romance or sex) and a lot of people just took that notion and ran with it.

Character Analysis » Sherlock- Asperger's syndrome and sociopathy » February 6, 2014 11:57 am

Mnemosyne
Replies: 259

Go to post

You can absolutely have a character who can have all these character traits and not have ASD. Sherlock could be a massive introvert. It might not be ASD at all.

But I can see why a lot of people have called BS on the 'sociopath' thing. The two things are not the same and I'm pretty sure (not an expert so let me know) that there is no such thing as a 'high functioning sociopath.'

This has led people to think why, as an adult, Sherlock would identify himself as something that people could fear. The primary conclusion that many have reached is that Sherlock would rather be feared than pitied. ASD is classed largely as a disability and therefore he risks being pitied by everyone and not being given the same opportunites. Sherlock therefore needs (in his mind) another reason to explain his behaviour to others that would invoke a 'better' response (not that I think being labelled a 'freak' by the likes of Sally Donovan is any better but there you go.)

I think the reason a lot of people have picked up on it is because it was mentioned in passing by John in THoB and Benedict has mentioned playing Sherlock as having Asperger's in some interviews.

I, personally, get the feeling Sherlock is on the spectrum. Because there is introvesion and then there's asking a man you barely know if your response to something was 'not good' because an overwhelming silence has just descended onto the room.

The Sign of Three » "Couple of Lightweights?" » February 6, 2014 11:08 am

Mnemosyne
Replies: 7

Go to post

As has been mentioned it it a derogatory comment flung at people who get drunk quickly, cannot hold their drink/have low alcohol tolerance.

The 'lightweights' comment made me think Lestrade was just being bitter over not being invited to the stag-do/pub crawl. Also explains why he screamed in John's ear whilst he had the mother of all hangovers. In this case it is Lestrade who is acting like a child (despite repeatedly insinuating that out of the two of them Sherlock is the childish one.)

General Sherlock Discussion » Would you still watch it if it was called "Shirley and Jamie"? » February 6, 2014 10:59 am

Mnemosyne
Replies: 19

Go to post

Mnemosyne wrote:

Harriet wrote:

If they would do it for some good reason, why not? I just can't see such reason at the moment...

If such a reason exists trust me I have not found it...
 

Oh my god, how rude does my comment look?! (I don't even remember writing that one.) I am so sorry.

If it were the identical show with just a change in gender to the characters I would give it a go but it probably wouldn't 'feel' the same for me. (I think it's because in my head they are 'stuck' as being male.)

Can anyone think of an original fictional equivalent to Sherlock and John (so I can read the hell out of it?) The concept in and of itself sounds genuinely fascinating, I'm just not sure if that could translate well onto screen.

Series Three Suggestions & Ideas » Who else is nervous/scared about His Last Vow? » January 10, 2014 8:24 am

Mnemosyne
Replies: 268

Go to post

When I think about HLV I feel like an addict worrying about when my next fix will be coming; whether it will be cut dangerously with something that might kill me. And like an addict I've got my nearest and dearest hooked on it, so at the moment we are all somewhat codependent.

Nervous is an understatement.

Series Three News » Urgent question to our British members » January 4, 2014 3:30 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 4

Go to post

I would have thought it to be a little bit odd if they aired everywhere in the UK but on the primary BBC One channel. A little self-defeating. Glad it's all worked out for you though

A Scandal In Belgravia » So what would YOU give Sherlock for Christmas? » January 1, 2014 5:17 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 61

Go to post

I am so very bad at choosing gifts it's not worth it. I'd probably get him an Amazon giftcard or something.

Meet The Members » Anyone else on tumblr? » December 13, 2013 5:27 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 69

Go to post

Walks in...
Makes a note of everyone...
Walks out...
Follows everyone...
Continues to lurk... *shifty eyes*

Meet The Members » What does your username/signature/avatar say about you? » December 10, 2013 10:42 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 172

Go to post

Oh wow, so many more!

@maggi13: I'd love to see Simon on Sherlock... Erm, I'd best be careful with that sentence because I'm certain that could be misconstrued 

@FluteLocked: thank you very much, I don't often create threads so it's nice to see I haven't made a totall mess of it and it is something that others actually enjoy discussing.

@Wholocked: I watched NT Frankenstein about two months ago at a cinema on Halloween. It was a wonderful experience. I had already read the stageplay (and the novel by that token) so I knew what was going to happen but there is no substitute so seeing it fully realised on stage.

@Neptune Centari: I picked my username out years ago too. I have a few 'go to' names that I swap out and change every few years.

@NiTeLight: Practically using your personality as your Username, I like that. I got tested aaaaages ago by a bloke from the navy (of all things) I turned out to be INFJ... he took me to one side and calmly said 'this is probably not a valid career choice for you.'

@Placebo: Placebo! I love them too. They were the soundtrack to my adolescence... Oh god, showing my age there.
 

Other » Free Rants » October 18, 2013 2:39 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 2423

Go to post

kittykat wrote:

Holier-than-thou types who think they know everything about other people...

*rolls eyes*

 
Well they sound...<mild phrasing> exceedingly unsociable </mild phrasing>

Other » Free Rants » October 7, 2013 10:13 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 2423

Go to post

madwitch58 wrote:

I have had a very bad few weeks. I work now for a fast food place, for minamum, get no brakes most of the time on my feet all night, got bad knees from a car crash a few years ago, am 55 years old, most of my coworkers are too young to drink, so they spend most of the time they are suposed to be working playing. Costemers act like this is a four star place, I mean come one people this is one of the cheapes fast food places there is, you get what you pay for. We had one gut try to start a fight witrh some one he did not know over a girl, I had to throw him out. Not an easy job I can tell you. My husband and son can not find work yet, so that leaves me to pay the bills. 
On the bright side I have a good shot at geting a better paying , easyer job soon.  
As for the goverment I think Sherlock could best call them what they are. Thank you all for leting me get that  out. Every one of you rock. OOXX

I too have spent my fair share of long hours waiting tables at restaurants and people who have never done it cannot imagine the pain you feel in your legs (not to mention your entire body) by the time 4am rolls around and when you finally do get home you end up lying awake in bed in some sort of stupour because you can't 'switch off'.

You are doing really well and I wish you luck in getting a better (and much more deserving) job xx.
 

Other » Free Rants » October 5, 2013 4:09 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 2423

Go to post

I feel for both of you being stuck in the middle of this mess. I have to be honest and say, at first, I didn't get what was going on. But now I've read up on it I'm surprised to say I 'understand' it even less. It's ridiculous! Ordinary people should not have to suffer the consequences.

General Sherlock Discussion » Will fingerpaint stain glass? » September 30, 2013 4:55 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 3

Go to post

I really don't think so (fingerpaints are often designed to come off nearly anything because young children will fingerpaint on anything) but to be sure you're better off testing a small area or another glass object, leaving it for a day or two and then wiping it off and see how it looks.

Also, and I'm sure you've thought of this, but be careful which side you paint it on. The last thing you want is to get the paint smudged the first time anyone opens that door.

Latest News » Andrea Plunket: The woman threatening to take BBC Sherlock off the air » September 21, 2013 10:16 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 23

Go to post

sj4iy wrote:

Also keep in mind that the article is from the Daily Fail.

Daily Fail... ahaha I am definitely going to refer to them like that from now on.
 

Latest News » Andrea Plunket: The woman threatening to take BBC Sherlock off the air » September 20, 2013 1:51 pm

Mnemosyne
Replies: 23

Go to post

I always think that writers and artists of any kind should always get correctly rewarded for the work they do and should not have to face being ripped off, copied etc whilst they are alive. But the thought of any work I do being squabbled over like this in 100 years time really makes my blood run cold. I think if you're not a blood relation and you were not mentioned in a will somewhere, forget it, you're not entitled to it. (I just wish there was a way to stop these hangers on who married someone to lay claim to their intellectual property.)

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum