BBC Sherlock Fan Forum - Serving Sherlockians since February 2012.


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

The Final Problem » The Final Problem: First impressions » January 15, 2017 11:12 pm

Tinks
Replies: 359

Go to post

Hi everyone. I don't post too much these days - sorry for that - I didn't know whether to share my thoughts or not, but because I so loved the show I want to just say what I feel somewhere before I draw a line under it.
I didn't like season 4 at all - in fact it's left me feeling like I don't really have the energy to fully explain why.
And this finale. For me it was messy, ridiculous, full of holes - I feel like I have to make it up to myself somehow by reading the ACD stories again so that I can erase all this from my mind.
Mofftiss are clever - we know that. But I find myself wishing they'd called this show something else; I wish they'd made their own characters and given them different names in the way that the creators of House did.
I'm too tired to articulate properly so I'll just finish by saying that this felt like the end, but even if they did more, I'm out now.

The Six Thatchers » First impressons and discussions » January 3, 2017 9:26 am

Tinks
Replies: 385

Go to post

SolarSystem wrote:



Apart from that: Yes, not enough John, too much Mary, 221B felt totally alien to me... at this point I have completely lost touch with the show.
 

This sums up exactly how I feel.
That's all I can really say for now.

Benedict's Non-Sherlock Work » Hamlet at the Barbican - contains spoilers about the production » September 1, 2015 9:37 am

Tinks
Replies: 514

Go to post

Hi everyone
I saw it a couple of nights ago - here's my personal view:

I thought the set design was absolutely stunning.
The production was very absorbing - it certainly didn't feel as though I'd sat there for over three hours!
Benedict's performance was very, very good indeed; he's so at home on the stage, and with Shakespeare
Honestly? I'd have liked to see some stronger casting alongside him - one performance in particular didn't sit right with me - maybe it was the direction, I don't know, but it was the only time I was not lost in the show, when this character had their "big" moment.
The rest of the cast were good but not, in my opinion, outstanding.
On the whole though I enjoyed it immensely as did my non-Shakespeare loving, non-Benedict fan partner, who thought both the play and Benedict were "excellent"

Awards » BAFTA 2015 (for Television) » April 27, 2015 5:27 pm

Tinks
Replies: 52

Go to post

He's up against very tough competition though, as both Toby Jones and Jason Watkins were absolutely fantastic in their roles and very highly praised for their performances; I've a strong hunch it will be one of them who wins (but I'm always wrong!)

Upcoming Events & Competitions » Sherlocked - The Official Sherlock Convention » April 27, 2015 2:48 pm

Tinks
Replies: 976

Go to post

What a lovely report from Iillithiell
I just popped in to say that I hope all who attended the con had a fantastic time. I've been having a sneaky peek on Twitter over the weekend so I know some of our old friends had the time of their lives and that Andrew Scott, Rupert Graves and Louise Brealey were particularly appreciated.
I'm sorry to hear that Benedict was struggling with a head cold - I get the impression that due to this, and the huge numbers of people he had to pose with, it was a bit of a blur for those that did have a photoshoot with him, which is a bit of a shame, but lovely to know that everyone came away feeling so happy

And slightly off topic, but just want to say "hi" to everyone and hope you're all well

Benedict's Non-Sherlock Work » Oscars » February 23, 2015 3:33 pm

Tinks
Replies: 211

Go to post

LOL, tonnaree :D
Seriously though, I honestly, sincerely, don't feel sore at all about Benedict not winning; I absolutely didn't expect him to anyway.
But I stand by my belief that Eddie is not an outstanding actor, but that the judges were more swayed by the role he was playing - in my opinion there were other actors who gave far better performances this year who weren't even nominated.
But it's all about opinion, isn't it?

Benedict's Non-Sherlock Work » Oscars » February 23, 2015 3:07 pm

Tinks
Replies: 211

Go to post

It's so true that you absolutely cannot say definitively that this or that movie/actor is. " the best" and that many many extremely talented actors never ever won a major award.
Tim Spall has already been mentioned; he's a fantastic, very underrated actor.
I thought Jake Gyllenhaal was great in Nightcrawler, too, but he was also overlooked.
The Oscars are what they are and shouldn't be taken too seriously, imo - it's the quality of an actors body of work that says the most about them.

Benedict's Non-Sherlock Work » Oscars » February 23, 2015 9:48 am

Tinks
Replies: 211

Go to post

Completely agree with everything you say there, nakahara

Benedict's Non-Sherlock Work » Oscars » February 23, 2015 8:10 am

Tinks
Replies: 211

Go to post

I'm not criticising Ben for not campaigning the way others do - I think that's a ridiculous part of the whole thing anyway - I just think it became obvious that Eddie (or rather his PR people - or both!) - had nailed that part of it.
Ridiculous that people are trying to make BCs parents look bad - everyone knew that ER was pretty much certain to win it; why should they say otherwise?

Benedict's Non-Sherlock Work » Oscars » February 23, 2015 7:45 am

Tinks
Replies: 211

Go to post

My thoughts, for what they're worth:
I think the role itself won Eddie the Oscar - as others have said, physically demanding roles like this are usually well rewarded, not to mention Stephen Hawking being a highly esteemed figure.
I'll also stick my head above the parapet and say that Eddie conducted a perfect campaign - you could tell by the way the media took to him that he was this years' "darling"
But for me, personally, he is the least really outstanding actor that I've ever seen win an Oscar - I've never seen him a role other than TTOE where he's anything other than bland.
For all that though, he seems like a nice guy so good luck to him!
I'm glad TIG won SOMETHING at last - so many critics were far too sniffy about the Movie, and really unfairly so.
It would have been the icing on the cake to see Benedict get an Oscar, but it's all very subjective and not always based on the performance alone; I don't think he'll be too disappointed, and I don't think he was ever a front runner for the award either - that's just the way these things go.
If I'm being REALLY honest, the performance that I personally enjoyed the most this year, didn't even get a nomination! :D.

Benedict's Press » Benedict is a Married Man! » February 15, 2015 11:34 am

Tinks
Replies: 89

Go to post

Firstly: an apology - I'm cranky this morning and I'm painfully aware that I'm commenting on things that I'd usually stay silent on.
Secondly: I'm only stating my personal opinion and I'm fully aware and accept that others can and probably will disagree with me.
I'm saying this because I don't, as a rule, carry on with a debate for too long because I like and respect everyone on here and don't want to appear to be "arguing" with anyone.


But I feel that Amanda knows, by now, how people react to certain things and it's very easy to stop these over reactions occurring or at least to put a stop to them as soon as they start by clarifying matters.
She always seems to choose not to.

Which of course is a choice she's fully entitled to make.

Benedict's Press » Benedict is a Married Man! » February 15, 2015 9:49 am

Tinks
Replies: 89

Go to post

Harriet wrote:

Well, she makes jokes about him on Twitter, so she might as well congratulate him on Twitter, esp when she mentions his wedding.

 
This sums things up very nicely, and is much more to the point than my waffling

Benedict's Press » Benedict is a Married Man! » February 15, 2015 9:47 am

Tinks
Replies: 89

Go to post

Kerkerian wrote:

JenHart wrote:

Tinks wrote:

I have to say, it was obvious that the story about Martin being best man was rubbish; you can tell from Amanda's tweets that they are not close to Ben at all; even when she made it known that the story was untrue, she didn't wish any happiness or congrats to the couple - just pointed out that the idea of MF being his best man was making her laugh!
Anyway, that aside, I wish them, as I'd wish all newlyweds, a long and happy life together.

 
I'm surprised she didn't at least congratulate them, after all, they have met, and Martin and Ben have filmed together for some years.

Just because Amanda didn't do it via twitter (and why should she, since Ben isn't even on it), it doesn't necessarily mean that she and Martin didn't congratulate them. They may not be close friends, but they'll have each other's contact info.

 
It's true that they could congratulate him privately - for me though, there's just something about AA's behaviour on Twitter where BC is concerned; she could simply have stated that MF wasn't Best Man but she "laughed" at the very idea of it - as though the very notion he'd be a Best Man to BC was ridiculous; she's intelligent - even when further questioned she still didn't qualify her comment by wishing him all the best, and she'll know what some will take from that.
He's not on twitter, it's true, but it doesn't mean she couldn't have said something nice.
On his Oscar nomination, for instance, other colleagues tweeted their congrats - the only comment AA made was to say that no, the cast wouldn't be taking time out from filming to watch the nominations come in.
Anyway, my apologies for dragging the thread off topic, and I hope I don't come over as too  cynical about this; it's just an interpretation I have of this particular situation.

Benedict's Press » Benedict is a Married Man! » February 15, 2015 9:08 am

Tinks
Replies: 89

Go to post

miriel68 wrote:

The thing about Martin being a close friend with Benedict is a fantasy born from a projection of the series into real life, but I am a bit surprised that newspapers bought this fiction as well. I remember Martin telling clearly in one of the interviews that they only reunite for doing Sherlock and don't really meet outside the set. In fact, we have never seen them together in any social occasion, if I remember correctly. Well, Benedict went to see Martin's Richard III, but that's another matter.

 
Even without knowing them personally, I think it's clear that they are two completely different people with little, or nothing, in common...the kind whose paths would never usually cross.
I've seen a comment elsewhere from someone saying that they don't actually get on, and that Martin doesn't like Ben. I don't know about that, but I can well believe that Ben's background is the complete opposite of all that Martin knows and believes in; they're like chalk and cheese.
Which I guess makes the chemistry they pull off on screen all the more awe inspiring.
Anyway, back on topic - even though I'm not a Hiddles fan, I have to say he looks really dashing in his wedding outfit

Benedict's Press » Benedict is a Married Man! » February 15, 2015 8:58 am

Tinks
Replies: 89

Go to post

JenHart wrote:

Tinks wrote:

JenHart, what a beautiful story yours is - I don't mean to sound silly but it gave my heart a lift; that you and your man found and fell in love with each other (I hope you don't mind my saying that).

)

 
Actually we met when I fell on him on some public transport and I thought that he was gorgeous And no I don't mind you saying the above. Thank you. If Ben and Sophie are as happy as we have been they will be blessed indeed and I don't see why they shouldn't be as the way they look at each other is very loving.

 
That's really lovely

Benedict's Press » Benedict is a Married Man! » February 15, 2015 8:39 am

Tinks
Replies: 89

Go to post

JenHart, what a beautiful story yours is - I don't mean to sound silly but it gave my heart a lift; that you and your man found and fell in love with each other (I hope you don't mind my saying that).

I was going to say more about Amanda with regard to Ben, but it's probably not wise to do so.
Back to the Best Man stuff though, I hope Adam was able to be there for him

General Benedict Appreciation » Let's talk all things lovely about Ben... » February 15, 2015 8:09 am

Tinks
Replies: 1761

Go to post

And me!
I hope they are happy and I wish them well for the future, but aside from that I don't have a huge interest in his personal life with his wife and baby.
I want to see more of his work and would love him to get more and more recognition as an actor.
I do feel uncomfortable though, about the obsessive and bitter stuff that some people are - publicly - posting.
Some of it is potentially career harming and, therefore, imo, some of these haters are quite sinister.

Benedict's Press » Benedict is a Married Man! » February 15, 2015 7:58 am

Tinks
Replies: 89

Go to post

I have to say, it was obvious that the story about Martin being best man was rubbish; you can tell from Amanda's tweets that they are not close to Ben at all; even when she made it known that the story was untrue, she didn't wish any happiness or congrats to the couple - just pointed out that the idea of MF being his best man was making her laugh!
Anyway, that aside, I wish them, as I'd wish all newlyweds, a long and happy life together.

Upcoming Events & Competitions » Sherlocked - The Official Sherlock Convention » February 11, 2015 10:50 am

Tinks
Replies: 976

Go to post

Yes, the part about paying to have a picture taken with someone - at this, or any other con, is something that I, personally, don't feel comfortable with. Not that I'm saying that actors should appear for free - of course they shouldn't be expected to give up their time for nothing - but paying for them to put their arm around me and smile and then forget all about me just wouldn't appeal to me (I know, I know - I'm a bit weird:D)
I do feel sorry for those that are disappointed in not being able to go though - especially due to the short notice given...in that respect it all feels a bit "take it or leave it" which isn't really fair.
Coming back to the pricing; it's very true and very sad that it's long been the case that those who can pay more get the better experience from cons, concerts, sports events, etc.
Lip service is paid to organisers wanting everyone to have the chance to experience - say - a Theatre production, but it's not the SAME experience as it most often involves restricted viewing.
I was having a similar discussion with someone about Football matches recently - certainly in my country, a game that was always the working persons' sport, is more and more pricing those working people out of going to watch it.
It does leave a sour taste in the mouth, but it's the same all over, sadly.

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum